NEW YORK — Fashion’s battle over red has ended with a white flag.
After a highly publicized legal tug of war that lasted a year and a half, Yves Saint Laurent SA said Tuesday that it will drop its lawsuit against Christian Louboutin SA.
Claiming it won a “conclusive” victory, YSL said it is ready to “close the book” on what had become one of the most widely scrutinized legal cases in the fashion world.
Louboutin sued YSL in April 2011, claiming the fashion house infringed on the footwear brand’s trademark when it sold red pumps with red soles. Presiding New York federal court judge Victor Marrero disagreed with Louboutin, and allowed YSL to continue to sell the monochrome shoes. The judge went a step further by questioning the validity of Louboutin’s trademark.
With its mark in jeopardy, the French shoemaker appealed the decision, and in January, Louboutin lawyer Harley Lewin argued his client’s case before a packed courtroom, which included industry figures such as Council of Fashion Designers of America president Diane von Furstenberg, CFDA chief executive officer Steven Kolb and an apprehensive Christian Louboutin.
“From our perspective, the Appeals Court decision was a complete victory for us,” said YSL lawyer David Bernstein. “We got the right to sell the shoes and the court even narrowed Louboutin’s trademark. It’s our hope that Louboutin will stop using the [trademark] registration in an anticompetitive way.”
While YSL dismissed its counterclaims that essentially called into question how Louboutin procured its trademark, Bernstein said his client still has a “very strong” case to cancel Louboutin’s registration should the brand attempt another lawsuit.
“There’s little reason for us to pursue the cancelation at this point,” he said. “We’ve already won and there’s no reason to be vindictive.”
But Louboutin’s Lewin shrugged off Bernstein’s aggressive words, calling the claims “counter threats” that are “not substantive” and difficult to prove.
Essentially, YSL would have to bring the matter to the United States Patent and Trademark Office and make the case that the patent office that granted Louboutin its mark had done so fraudulently. Not only would that be a lot of trouble but it would also further strain an already frayed relationship between two leading industry brands. Ending in a truce of sorts may also help heal the precarious personal relationship between Christian Louboutin and François-Henri Pinault, chairman and ceo of PPR, YSL’s parent company, according to sources familiar with the matter.
Now that YSL has a new direction under creative director Hedi Slimane, Lewin hopes that the house, which is now known as Saint Laurent, will steer clear of producing shoes that ruffle Louboutin’s feathers. While the lawyer noted that under common law his client still has a case against brands that produce all-red shoes, he too seemed content to call the legal battle a truce.
“Now that Pepsi and Coke have fought over the formula, I must say, in my 40-year career, I’ve never seen a case go more wide than this one,” Lewin remarked. “It had a celebrity, fashion and legal side to it but once the consumer got involved, that changed the face of the case. It was tried in the courtroom and the court of public opinion.”
"'Dynasty' is all about gowns, the diamonds and the scandal, so it's a bit like the fashion industry. When we come to Cannes it's all about the red carpet dresses too, so it all fit really well," said designer @philippplein78 on the theme of his high-glamour resort 2019 show at his mansion in Cannes. #wwdfashion #cannes (📷: @zefashioninsider)
"I think Spike is such a brilliant director because he holds up a mirror to society and reflects these issues, yet he doesn't shove it down your throat, he doesn't tell you what to think," says @lauraharrier on her latest film @Blackkklansman. Harrier was at the Cannes Film Festival – for the very first time – with @officialspikelee. #wwdeye #cannes (📷: @zefashioninsider)
“I would think to myself, Are you happy? Yes, I’m wildly happy. I go to this studio every day and, in my inside voices, I’m giggling; I’m singing. Yes, it’s a lot of work, it’s a [huge] volume of material. It wouldn’t be for everybody. But I was very happy,” said soap opera star @therealsusanlucci of checking in throughout the years with her career trajectory. Lucci spoke to WWD about her decades-long career, love for pilates, motherhood and her QVC activewear line. Read Bridget Foley’s full piece on Lucci on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: @celestesloman)
@balmain has taken a stand at the #cannes Film Festival, dressing 16 actresses at a press call for the project “Noire N’est Pas Mon Metier,” or “Black Is Not My Profession.” The multimedia project includes a book, photo exhibit and documentary, which aims to expose discrimination in the French and American entertainment industries. “The moment I was asked to participate, I knew it was right for me, and for this brand, to form a part of this moment,” Balmain creative director @olivier_rousteing told WWD. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
"I always feel curious and I feel like there's more to learn. But I think being relevant, feeling relevant, I personally always feel that there's just so much more to know. And maybe that's the key.” — @themarcjacobs #wwdsummits #wwdbeauty (📷: @patrickmacleodphoto )
“The most amazing thing about her is that, regardless of all the things that have happened to her, her spirit is so undaunted by all of it. She is the most cheerful person you will ever meet. She doesn’t see problems, she only sees solutions,” said @ajanaomi_king of activist Ifrah Ahmed, who she plays in a new film “A Girl from Mogadishu.” WWD caught up with King at Cannes — Head to WWD.com to read more about her new role, personal style and how she uses social media for causes like Time’s Up and Black Lives Matter #wwdeye
WWD asked a number designers to share their thoughts on what Meghan Markle’s wedding gown will look like this Saturday. Here, Valentino’s Pierpaolo Piccioli sketches his look. #wwdfashion #royalwedding #meghanmarkle