NEW YORK — Lawyers for Yves Saint Laurent made a federal court of appeals deadline to file its response in the Christian Louboutin red-sole trademark appeal before yearend.
The YSL attorneys filed their appellate brief on Tuesday.
The dispute began in April, when Louboutin sued YSL in a New York federal court in Manhattan, claiming that YSL’s red pump violated its red-sole trademark. In August, the presiding judge denied Louboutin’s request for a preliminary injunction and instead questioned the validity of the trademark, which Louboutin obtained in 2008.
District court Judge Victor Marrero concluded that no one designer should have a “monopoly” on any color. He also rejected Louboutin’s arguments that infringing on its trademark would cause “irreparable harm” and that YSL’s shoe caused “consumer confusion.”
Louboutin’s attorneys appealed the decision and in October filed their appellate brief focused on Judge Marrero’s “errors of law” in determining that Louboutin’s red outsole mark was invalid.
In the court document filed Tuesday, YSL argued that Louboutin cannot overcome the “formidable hurdle” necessary to obtain a reversal of the lower court’s denial of the request for a preliminary injunction. YSL said appellate review of the denial is based on an abuse of discretion, a deferential standard that shouldn’t be disturbed so long as it “falls within a range of permissible decisions.” It argued that functionality in trademark cases has long been treated as a question of fact reviewed under the clear error standard. YSL also cited a case in which a court determined that when there are two permissible views of the evidence, the fact finder’s “choice between them cannot be clearly erroneous.”
YSL also argued that there were other reasons why the lower court’s decision should be upheld, such as Louboutin’s inability to show “irreparable harm” and a failure to establish a secondary meaning for the red-colored trademark.
What seems key, however, is whether there’s even enough of a record of evidence and documents for the district court to rule as it did.
As expected, that’s a key point in both the Louboutin and YSL briefs on file with the appellate court. Louboutin said the undeveloped record precluded any definitive ruling on the functionality issue. YSL, in its brief, argued that Louboutin’s admission of the lack of a record should mean that substantive appellate review should wait until a final decision is made on the merits, one based on a fully developed transcript of the issues and documents presented before the court.
Harley I. Lewin, a partner at McCarter & English, which represents Louboutin, said, “We have taken a quick review [of the brief and], there are no surprises here. YSL essentially is mirroring the arguments it used at the lower level, which is entirely expected.”
According to Lewin, a hearing date has been set for Jan. 24 for oral argument in the afternoon before the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan.
“We are pretty confident our brief is persuasive. Nonetheless, it remains the decision of the Court of Appeals at the end of the day,” Lewin said.
@zacposen's go-to holiday gift? Cookies! "I'll usually bake cookies and send them as a gift," said the designer, who recently released his cookbook "Cooking With Zac: Recipes from Rustic to Refined." Get the recipe for his Brown Butter-Chocolate Chip Cookies via link in bio 🍪🍪🍪 #wwdeye #cookingwithzac
For @monsemaison’s pre-fall 2018 collection, Fernando Garcia and Laura Kim honed in on the brand’s many signatures — men’s wear, which was tweaked and feminized through deconstruction, proportion play and lots of bare shoulders. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: George Chinese)
On Friday night, @yohjiyamamotoofficial received the Design for Asia Lifetime Achievement Award in Hong Kong. The 75-year-old designer has been celebrated for many years and is best known for his dark and avant-garde tailoring. “In my long career, in design, architecture, [I’ve been to] so many parties, this is the very first time that I have such a warm feeling, I really appreciate this,” Yamamoto said. #wwdfashion (📷: @dominiquemaitre)
Discovery is collaborating with British pop artist @philipcolbert on a new line of clothing and accessories called Discovery Shark. The collection, which will launch next summer for Shark Week’s 30th anniversary, features a whimsical line of women’s and men’s bomber jackets, sweatshirts, bags and more. #wwdfashion
“I’m always a big champion of a female rapper, and I’m glad to see a new voice that feels unique and authentic that’s coming up, and I think we’re going to see more great things from her,” said @itsjeremyscott about @iamcardib, who performed at @moschino’s Art Basel Miami Beach party last night. #wwdeye (📷: @lexieblacklock)
@janellemonae’s “What’s Your Frequency?” room in @refinery29's #29Rooms made its debut this week at the opening of the Los Angeles art exhibit. “It’s about the ongoing conversation around mass surveillance, the weaponization of technology and cultural uniformity. My space was created so that we can come together and talk about the complexities of our humanity,” said Monáe. #wwdeye (📷: @bucknerphoto)
@pantone announced their Color of the Year 2018: Ultra Violet. Nearly 20 months after the musician Prince’s death, fashion is having a purple moment. Varying shades of purple appeared on spring or fall runways, from @christopherkane to @calvinklein. @gucci’s Alessandro Michele bathed his fall runway in ultra violet-colored light at one point. Pantone 18-3838 is meant to “push the boundaries of what inspires us to look upward and outward to the future.” #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @kukukuba)