The completion on Nov. 2 of a long-awaited report concluding that the cosmetics giant broke French laws by cooperating with an Arab League boycott against Israel has reignited a nasty three-year controversy pitting L'Oreal against French-Jewish organizations and involving Israel.
In addition, the U.S. Commerce Department has been asked to look into the report, according to an executive at the American Jewish Congress.
News accounts of the report began appearing in the French press last week.
"The top managers at L'Oreal clearly expressed their intention to follow the rules of the very boycott that French legislation had no less clearly condemned," wrote David Ruzie, a French professor of international law, who prepared the report and who was a co-author of France's 1977 anti-boycott law.
Although L'Oreal agreed in December 1991 to have an independent investigator look into the closing in 1989 of a Helena Rubinstein factory in Israel and its correspondence with the Arab League, the company Monday rejected Ruzie's report.
"We never accepted Mr. Ruzie as the investigator. He showed himself to be biased from the start," said Gerard Unger, a L'Oreal spokesman.
"Furthermore, his report is incomplete and does not shed any new light on this matter," Unger continued. "We have seen all these documents before."
Ruzie conceded that he had analyzed only documents that had been leaked to the press. Most of them, including letters from L'Oreal executives responding to questionnaires from Arab officials, belonged to papers seized during court-ordered searches of L'Oreal headquarters and homes of executives in March 1991.
Ruzie said L'Oreal could not be prosecuted in France, however, because the law's three-year statute of limitations had expired.
According to Will Maslow, general counsel of the American Jewish Congress in New York, the Commerce Department is weighing a request to investigate whether Cosmair Inc., the American licensee of L'Oreal, violated U.S. laws prohibiting participation in the Arab League boycott of Israel.
The request was made two months ago by Gil Frydman, a nephew of Jean and David Frydman, who were involved in a dispute that is at the root of the controversy.Maslow said he urged Gil Frydman, who lives in New York, to ask Commerce's Office of Antiboycott Compliance to review the L'Oreal case.
"They said they would look into it," Maslow said. Gil Frydman could not be reached for comment. An official with the boycott office declined to confirm or deny the existence of a L'Oreal inquiry.
Maslow said it's uncertain whether the U.S. would have any jurisdiction over the L'Oreal case.
"There has to be a violation in American commerce," Maslow said. "Either the French company had to do it here, or an American subsidiary." A spokeswoman for Cosmair said she is unaware if the firm was contacted.
Ruzie said the case against L'Oreal hinged on the Israeli plant shutdown in 1989. L'Oreal has maintained that the closing was just one of 25 around the world done for financial reasons.
The firm confirmed a report that L'Oreal chairman Lindsay Owen-Jones had lunch on Nov. 25 with Uri Savir, managing director of the Israeli foreign ministry, and Jean Kahn, president of the Representative Council of Jewish Institutions in France.
According to the Israeli publication Globes, during the lunch Savir turned down L'Oreal's offer of financial reparation and asked instead for an apology and for the company to reopen the Rubinstein plant in Israel.
The L'Oreal spokesman declined to confirm those details but said the possibility of investing in Israel was discussed. The dispute at the heart of the affair is between former L'Oreal chairman Francois Dalle and Jean Frydman, a former executive with Paravision, the L'Oreal film distribution subsidiary.
Dalle founded Paravision with Frydman, who subsequently left the company. In a French civil suit, Frydman claimed he was forced out of Paravision because of his business ties to Israel in an effort by L'Oreal to end the Arab boycott of its products, which lasted from early 1988 -- the year Rubinstein was acquired -- until July 1989.
Frydman agreed in December 1991 to drop charges against Dalle in exchange for a letter of apology and an inquiry into whether L'Oreal violated the 1977 boycott law.
An independent investigator, Jean-Louis Bismuth, a co-author along with Ruzie of the boycott legislation, was appointed and L'Oreal agreed to finance his investigation. But Bismuth died last April before completing his report.At that time, some Jewish groups proposed that Ruzie complete Bismuth's inquiry but L'Oreal refused to accept him, charging that he had already decided that the firm was guilty.
Ruzie prepared his report independently with the backing of key French Jewish organizations.
The L'Oreal spokesman said the company would still be willing to cooperate with an investigation into the boycott. However, nine months later L'Oreal still has not proposed a replacement for Bismuth.
"Believe me, I have searched myself for a suitable candidate," said L'Oreal attorney Jean Veil. "I wanted a Jewish person and I wanted a specialist in this area and I could not find anyone who wanted to accept."
--with contributions from JOANNA RAMEY and CAROL EMERT, Washington
In his new book “Hollywood Royale,” Andy Warhol’s Protégé Matthew Rolston celebrates the Eighties revival of Hollywood glamour. Featuring more than 100 portraits taken by Rolston from 1977 to 1993, the book contains photos of icons like Michael Jackson, Cyndi Lauper, and @drewbarrymore, pictured here in 1991. “Hollywood Royale,” out today, will be accompanied by an exhibition opening at Los Angeles’ Fahey/Klein Gallery on March 1. #wwdeye
"Nowadays when life is not so happy with everything going on in the world, I think people come to me for a little bit of whimsy and color and fun." - Designer Rebecca De Ravenel on her cult-favorite jewelry line. (📸 : @vsteves) #wwd40
“Everyone is talking about how the retail industry is struggling, but I think it’s an incredible time because brands who are doing something different and innovative are setting themselves up for the future,” said @adamgoldston, who founded the luxury athletic brand @apl with his brother @ryangoldsten. The Goldston’s are part of WWD’s 40 under 40: a group of industry notables. See the rest of the list on WWD.com. (📷: @vsteves) #wwd40
@eyeswoon blogger Athena Calderone debuted her first-ever cookbook, “Cook Beautiful,” which is heavily centered on the presentation and visual expression of food. Pictured here are her miso glazed carrots from the book. Get the recipe on WWD.com. (📷: @johnny_miller_) #wwdeye
“It’s passion that helps get anybody to a certain point and it’s what’s propelled me,” said Kith founder @ronniefieg, one of WWD’s 40 under 40: a group of industry notables who are changing the face of retail, fashion and beauty. Fieg, who opened a Manhattan flagship on October 7, began his career at age 13 as a stock boy and salesman for footwear chain David Z. “I think staying true to [my] beliefs, hard work and passion have gotten me to where [Kith] is today.” See the rest of the 40 at WWD.com. (📷: @vsteves) #wwd40
25-year-old @samweaving is about to break out this fall, starring in Netflix’s horror film “The Babysitter,” fittingly out today on Friday the 13th. That’s not the only place you’ll be seeing her, though — Weaving’s got a role Showtime’s “SMILF” and another alongside Frances McDormand and Woody Harrelson in “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri.” Though she’s got a full plate at the moment, there’s one role she’s got her eye on: Marilyn Monroe. “I’m a little too young at the moment, but it’s on my bucket list,” the actress told WWD (📷: @dandoperalski) #wwdeye
BFF's Poppy Jamie and Suki Waterhouse celebrated the launch of their bag line Pop x Suki at Nordstrom last night. "The line is really about our friendship, and how we are so different but complement each other," said Waterhouse. 👯 (📷: Katie Jones) #wwdeye
After designing the new @louisvuitton and @bulgariofficial flagships and a @chanelofficial boutique opening in Japan, @petermarinoarchitect has another project on his plate: The Lobster Club. Located in the Seagram Building, it’s the famed architect’s first restaurant project in New York, serving up modern Japanese brasserie-style cuisine. Bronze hues, bespoke material detailing, blush and chartreuse tones and a heavy emphasis on Picasso can be seen throughout. Mark your calendars for Nov. 1 for the much-anticipated opening. (📷: @clint_spaulding) #wwdeye
Did you know: @carlychaikin of "Mr. Robot" has been painting for about a decade? The actress, who plays Darlene on the show, is a self-taught artist who lists Salvador Dalí and Chuck Close as some of her idols. Chaikin told WWD that painting is a form of meditation for her — A much-needed one given the intensity of "Mr. Robot." See a piece Chaikin is working on at WWD.com (📷: @jilliansollazzo) #wwdeye