NEW YORK — In their war over the color red, both Christian Louboutin and Yves Saint Laurent are claiming major victories.
A New York federal appeals court backed the validity of Louboutin’s red-sole trademark Wednesday, but said the French shoemaker would only be able to protect its mark when it comes to red-soled shoes with contrasting uppers.
That caveat gives YSL the right to continue selling its monochrome pump — the shoe that spawned a lawsuit from Louboutin in April 2011 — and it also arguably gives YSL a slight advantage as the case moves back to New York federal court, which will now evaluate YSL’s counterclaims. RELATED STORY: Louboutin Forges Ahead With Trademark Battle >>
In short, Louboutin keeps his trademark, albeit under more restrictive terms, and YSL can keep selling all-red shoes.
YSL attorney David Bernstein called it a “stunning victory” for his client and said the court has “conclusively ruled that YSL’s monochromatic red shoes do not infringe any trademark rights of Louboutin, which guarantees that YSL can continue to make monochromatic shoes in a wide variety of colors, including red.”
In the initial suit, Louboutin alleged YSL violated its 2008 red-sole trademark by selling an all-red pump. Presiding federal court Judge Victor Marrero disagreed, denying Louboutin’s request and instead questioning the validity of the brand’s famous mark altogether. Lawyers for Louboutin appealed that decision just over a year ago.
Although Wednesday’s decision lifts the proverbial monopoly that Louboutin had on all-red shoes, the case also touches on a larger question — namely whether designers can use color as a trademark in fashion.
Brands such as Tiffany & Co. with its signature blue box; Hermès with its orange designs, and Cartier with its red packaging might have come under fire if the court cancelled Louboutin’s mark.
“The two key elements we sought answered were that color can be a trademark in the fashion industry and that our trademark is valid and enforceable — thank God,” said Harley Lewin, lawyer for Christian Louboutin, of the ruling.
That sentiment was shared by designer Diane von Furstenberg. Although she was not speaking on behalf of the Council of Fashion Designers of America, of which she serves as president, von Furstenberg lauded what she referred to as “great news” for Louboutin.
“All I can say is that it makes me have faith in the system,” she offered.
The legal community was a bit more even-handed on the verdict, dubbing the ruling a victory for both sides.
Lawyers pointed to the fact that the court upheld Judge Marrero’s denial of a preliminary injunction to stop the sale of the all-red pump, while simultaneously questioning his reading of how color is used as a trademark in fashion.
Judge Marrero had argued that no one should have a “monopoly” on a color, instead of examining whether the public associates red soles with Louboutin. That association, called “secondary meaning,” is vital in trademark cases, and the appeals court noted that the judge overlooked that tenant.
“Judge Marrero went way off the reservation with the last opinion,” said Susan Scafidi, director of Fordham University’s Fashion Law Institute, who underscored that Wednesday’s verdict provides a guideline for Marrero to view the rest of the case. “This decision is the equivalent of sending him a checklist. The legal community and fashion lawyers may have thought he had been getting bigger than his robe. This decision may have trimmed it back down to size.”
Setting that aside, Scafidi said the two parties would likely settle the matter out of court before proceeding further. Still, there is a chance that Louboutin and YSL will face off in court, as the case gets kicked back to Judge Marrero, who will now evaluate YSL’s counterclaims. In those claims, YSL seeks cancelation of Louboutin’s mark on the grounds that the Trademark and Patent Office awarded the trademark fraudulently. Proving that will be “extremely tough,” said Gibney Anthony & Flaherty partner Brian Brokate, who is an expert in intellectual property law.
“Still, I definitely think YSL has the advantage,” he said, remarking that YSL is now essentially the plaintiff, as the counterclaims are all that’s left to settle. “I’ve seen this before where one party bites off more than it can chew.”
Brokate was quick to point out that the appeals court did put in a unique provision in its order that would allow it to take over the case following any concerns over Marrero’s decision. Normally, this would require another long appeals process.
“I’ve never seen anything like this before,” Brokate said. “Clearly, the Court of Appeals is very interested in this issue and they want to see if something occurs outside the scope their opinion. But at the end of the day, I don’t think today’s verdict changes anything. It certainly confirms most of what we already knew, which is that a color can function as a trademark.”
As one of the most recognizable models in the world, Christy Turlington Burns has an insider’s view of the fashion industry and the allegations of sexual harassment swirling around it. “I can say that harassment and mistreatment have always been widely known and tolerated in the industry. The industry is surrounded by predators who thrive on the constant rejection and loneliness so many of us have experiences at some point in our careers,” Turlington told WWD, along with her suggestions for how the modeling world should protect younger women and men. Read more on WWD.com. Link in bio. (📷: Tony Palmieri) #wwdnews
@asics America has tapped a new brand ambassador: famed DJ/record producer @steveaoki. This initiative is intended to set the tone for the new brand identity and philosophy and will include partnerships with influencers and in-store and off-line activations that will continue into next year. This is Asics’ most significant marketing effort in two decades, and is expected to attract younger consumers to the brand. #wwdfashion
24-year-old Jean Prounis is redefining the rules of jewelry. Formerly a studio assistant to Jemima Kirke and a design apprentice at Ghuran, she focuses on handcrafted subtleties and ancient goldsmithing techniques. “There was a really sterile feel in the environment and I wanted to have jewelry with character that shapes how you wear it everyday,” Prounis said. Each piece is hand made in New York, either by Prounis or three other jewelers in the district. #wwdfashion
“These collections continue to build on that vision, empowering differently abled adults to express themselves through fashion,” said @tommyhilfiger of his line of adaptive apparel, which launches today. The line consists of 37 men’s and 34 women’s styles based upon the pieces from the spring Tommy Hilfiger sportswear collection. #wwdnews
“Stranger Things” is getting a new cast member for season 2. Meet @sadiesink_, the 15-year-old who will be joining the Netflix series for its new season. You may recognize her from “The Glass Castle” with Brie Larson and Woody Harrelson, but the Texas native’s next role goes in an entirely different direction. She describes her character, Max, as “a rough and tumble skater girl [who] becomes friends with the boys at school.” The second season debuts on October 27. (📷: @jgreenery) #wwdeye
Amid the Harvey Weinstein controversy, there’s another sector that’s being put under the spotlight for sexual abuse: the modeling industry. While rumors about abuse and sexual harassment of female and male models — and the photographers, agents and others who perpetrated it — have circulated within the fashion world for years, model @cameronrussell started posting stories from models on Instagram last week about abusive situations they’ve encountered — from sexual harassment and molestation to attempted rape. Over 75 have weighed in so far. Read more on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdnews
To celebrate its 16th anniversary, @dylanscandybar tapped designers and celebrities to create mosaics out of candy. The mosaics will be auctioned off to support the philanthropic cause of each participant’s choice. Pictured here is the mural created by @aliceandolivia's Stacey Bendet. For a first look at some of the other artwork being unveiled tonight, go to WWD.com. #wwdeye
The annual Veuve Clicquot Polo Classic in Pacific Palisades this weekend drew Kate Hudson, Tracee Ellis Ross, Laura Dern and more. See pictures of the star-studded event on WWD.com. (📷: @chelsealaurenla) #wwdeye
In his new book “Hollywood Royale,” Andy Warhol’s Protégé Matthew Rolston celebrates the Eighties revival of Hollywood glamour. Featuring more than 100 portraits taken by Rolston from 1977 to 1993, the book contains photos of icons like Michael Jackson, Cyndi Lauper, and @drewbarrymore, pictured here in 1991. “Hollywood Royale,” out today, will be accompanied by an exhibition opening at Los Angeles’ Fahey/Klein Gallery on March 1. #wwdeye