The highly contested battle over Christian Louboutin’s red-sole trademark is revving up anew.
Lawyers for Christian Louboutin filed their first brief to the Court of Appeals Monday, arguing for a reversal of an earlier ruling denying the fashion house a preliminary injunction and questioning the validity of its red-sole trademark.
The filing signals the beginning of an expedited appeal between Louboutin and defendant Yves Saint Laurent, which sold a red monochrome pump it created for its 2011 resort collection.
In April, Louboutin sued YSL in New York federal court, claiming that YSL’s red pump violated its red-sole trademark that it obtained in 2008. Louboutin asked the court to stop the sale of YSL’s shoe while the case was under review. But in August, presiding Judge Victor Marrero denied that request and instead questioned the validity of Louboutin trademark altogether.
Examining the function of color in fashion and its role in creativity, the judge told the plaintiff that no one designer should have a “monopoly” on any color.
Louboutin’s counsel argued that the color is vital to the brand’s DNA, and that infringing on its trademark would cause irreparable harm. It also claimed that YSL’s shoe caused “consumer confusion,” which is a critical component to determining if a trademark has been violated.
Those arguments didn’t convince the judge, and Louboutin quickly entered an appeal.
Filed Monday, the plaintiff’s appeal brief restates its arguments and focuses on what it deems as Judge Marrero’s “errors of law in determining that Louboutin’s red outsole mark was likely invalid.”
Louboutin’s “trademark status has been conferred upon it by the consuming public…only public recognition can breathe life into another mark, whether it be a single color, several colors or another design element,” according to the brief.
The court now awaits filings from YSL’s lawyers, who could not be reached for comment by press time.
“All the briefs from both sides are on a schedule that the Court of Appeals agreed with, to wit: all done and in before the end of the year,” Louboutin attorney Harley Lewin of McCarter & English LLP told WWD.
“Considering what is at stake, it is probably fair to assume a ruling sometime in early spring, if not earlier,” he said.
Breaking: @cushnieetochs’ co-founders @carlycushnie and @ochsmichelle are parting ways. After a 10-year run, Ochs is leaving the brand. Get the full story on WWD.com – link in bio. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
@maybelline’s Kanako Takase had snow bunnies in mind when creating the beauty look for @philipppleininternational. Playing off of the bedazzled snowboards in the collection, Takase mixed two highlighters together for a luminous sheen. #wwdbeauty #nyfw (📷: @jilliansollazzo)
“There’s a huge gap between the old way of doing things and today. It takes the youth to help evolve that. You have to count on the kids today to help lead you into the future. A lot of these retailers are stuck in the past. Communication is the biggest thing,” said @ronniefieg of @kith on the youth’s role in retail. On Monday night, Jeff Staple moderated a keynote session with Fieg and @syresmith at Assembly - a series of workshops, talks and keynotes addressing topics or issues in the apparel industry. Head to WWD.com to read more advice from Fieg and what Smith thinks of his dad @willsmith’s Instagram account and sustainability (📷: @weston.wells)
@joansmalls closed the @michaelkors fall 2018 show in black sequined pants and a varsity T printed with 19 on the front and 81 on the back. 1981 – the year Kors went into business. #wwdfashion #nfyw (📷: @giovanni_giannoni_photo)
“You think your life is going to be a certain way, and nothing you thought would happen ends up happening. Never in my wildest dreams did I think I’d be designing clothes and working with Mickey Drexler, and building something I’m deeply proud of,” said Jenna Lyons. Nine months after leaving @jcrew, Lyons is exploring the meaning of happiness. Read the interview, where Lyons talks about reinvention and more on WWD.com – link in bio. #wwdfashion (📷: Farrell) #jennalyons #jcrew