WASHINGTON — Brick-and-mortar retailers, which have long pushed for Internet sales tax fairness, applauded the Supreme Court’s refusal on Monday to hear a case filed by Amazon.com and Overstock.com Inc. challenging New York State’s law on collecting taxes on Internet purchases.
While satisfied with the High Court’s decision, retail trade groups said more needs to be done and stepped up the pressure on Congress to pass legislation to level the playing field between online sellers and traditional retailers.
Amazon and Overstock filed petitions for a writ of certiorari in August, charging that New York’s sales tax law violated the Commerce Clause by imposing tax-collection obligations on out-of-state retailers that have no physical presence in the state. The Internet retailers argued in their Supreme Court petitions that they had no physical presence in New York and should be exempt from collecting taxes on purchases made by New York customers.
The Supreme Court refused to consider their argument, letting stand a ruling by the New York Court of Appeals. The appeals court ruled in March that Amazon and Overstock were subject to the sales tax requirements in New York because the online retailers had contracts with local affiliates, such as blogs that post links to the Amazon and Overstock Web sites.
The debate over taxing Web sales has taken place in Washington and around the country for more than a decade without any resolution, but states have been enacting their own laws to close what they say is a loophole created in 1992 in Quill v. North Dakota, a Supreme Court ruling that stated retailers were required to collect sales tax from out-of-state customers only if they have a “physical presence” in the customer’s state.
E-tailers have relied on that decision to avoid collecting sales tax on online orders. Brick-and-mortar retailers, including those with e-commerce sites, that are typically required to collect sales taxes in states where they have stores, argue that puts them at a competitive price disadvantage.
In the absence of federal legislation, some states began changing the definition of what constitutes a physical presence in order to recoup what state lawmakers argued was billions of dollars in lost revenue in uncollected sales taxes from online sellers.
The New York legislature added a provision to its law in 2008 requiring retailers to collect sales taxes if the merchant solicited business through an independent contractor or third-party representative under two conditions: if the retailer gave commissions to New York State residents for referring customers to the retailer, and if the referrals generated more than $10,000 of sales annually, according to court documents.
“The statute serves an important function in facilitating the collection of millions of tax dollars that would otherwise be lost each year,” attorneys for the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance argued in court documents. “Although both [Amazon and Overstock] allege they have no physical presence in New York, they rely on affiliate programs under which they pay hundreds of thousands of representatives across the country, including thousands in New York, to drum up sales.”
Amazon has agreed to collect sales taxes in a handful of states, including California, Texas and Pennsylvania.
In Amazon’s case in California, for example, under a 2011 bill the physical presence was established by an affiliate company that manufactures the Kindle e-book readers in California’s Silicon Valley. Amazon also has distribution centers in California, which fell under the new definition.
A broad coalition of retailers has been pressing Congress for years to step in and replace the piecemeal state approach with federal legislation because some online retailers are still exempt from the different state-by-state definitions of what constitutes “nexus” or a physical presence and are not obligated to collect and remit sales taxes.
In April, the Senate passed legislation known as the Marketplace Fairness Act that would allow states to collect sales taxes from out-of-state online sellers regardless of whether they have a physical presence in the state. The bill provides for a small seller exemption that prohibits states from requiring remote sellers with less than $1 million in annual nationwide remote sales to collect sales and use taxes.
The legislation stalled in the House. House Judiciary Committee chairman Bob Goodlatte (R., Va.) has released a set of broad, general principles that he will consider in crafting his own legislation, industry groups said. But gridlock in Washington has made passage of legislation difficult and industry groups are now pinning their hopes on the legislation advancing next year.
“States have essentially tweaked nexus [physical presence] laws to require companies like Amazon to collect,” said Jason Brewer, vice president of communications and advocacy at the Retail Industry Leaders Association. “New York changed the definition of physical presence and basically said if you have affiliates, like Web advertisers, in the state, that counts as a physical presence and you must collect sales taxes. New York was the first state law trying to deal with this and other states took a different approach where they went after more physical building definitions, like distribution centers, to constitute a physical presence.”
Brewer noted that not every state has a Amazon warehouse, which has led to a patchwork of state laws on collecting sales taxes from online sellers.
“In order to have a comprehensive solution, you have to have federal legislation,” Brewer said. “That is ultimately what the states want. It is what retailers want. Our goal is to make this the last holiday season where brick-and-mortar retailers compete on an unlevel playing field.”
Rachelle Bernstein, vice president and tax counsel at the National Retail Federation, said, “What we believe is that the same tax should be charged to the same product sold in the same location. Whether you order over your computer or telephone and have it delivered to you at your house or go to a local mall to get it, you are getting the same product and should be subject to the same New York [in this case] sales tax.”
Bernstein said Monday’s Supreme Court decision “clearly shows the need for federal legislation to address this issue because we’ve got all of these different affiliate nexus laws in various states. There is a real need for clarity in this area.”
“What he has done at Vuitton is really exceptional,” said @gameofthrones’ actress Gwendoline Christie on @mrkimjones’ final show for @louisvuitton. “He has rebooted luxury in terms of making it commercial, viable and contemporary. And most importantly artistic. He has never compromised his artistic vision for the sake of commodity.” (📷: @zefashioninsider)
After seeing a demand for men’s wear from its customers, British contemporary women’s wear label @ariesarise has added a men’s wear component and will launch a unisex collection with @mrporterlive. The 20-piece collection includes jackets, denim, logo T-shirts and more with deconstructed ‘90s vibes. Set to launch on January 18, you can shop the pieces on Aries’ website and on mrporter.com. #wwdfashion
“And so spending so much time with a character who thinks like that, inevitability you try and analyze yourself and go back and think about your own demons and dark chapters that you had in your life,” says @thedanielbruhl of his role in TNT’s “The Alienist.” The show, set in the Gilded Age of New York, also stars Dakota Fanning and Luke Evans. Head to WWD.com to read about how 39-year-old Brühl prepared for the role and why he thinks the show is so relevant to today #wwdeye ( 📷: @Eriktanner)
Now that Celine Dion’s collection has topped $10 million in sales, the pop superstar, fashion icon and newly-minted industry player is eyeing growth in Asia. Read the full report by @tiffanyap, link in bio. #wwdnews #celinedion
“My personal philosophy to beauty is paying attention to oneself. I love to be outdoors, lots of fresh air, trying to take care of yourself as best you can. I always notice that comes through,” says Felicity Jones, the global face of @shiseido-owned @cledepeaubeauteus, which launches today. Head to WWD.com to read more about the actress’ love for beauty and how she prepared for her new role in “The Basis of Sex,” playing the young Ruth Bader Ginsburg. #wwdbeauty (📷: @dandoperalski)
Among the familiar faces at @off____white’s show was a surprise figure: Japanese artist @takashipom, pictured here on Wednesday morning. Other show-goers included @jerrylorenzo, who spoke about his upcoming project: a @nike collaboration for back to school, with designs inspired by his childhood on the West Coast. Sitting in the front row were Future, Don Crawley, @miguel and more. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: Stephane Feugere)
According to @laurentsai, former “Terrace House: Aloha State” cast member, she didn’t know she was auditioning for the Japanese version of “Real World.” “I was telling a couple of my friends and someone’s like, ‘That sounds a lot like Terrace House.’ I was like, ’No it can’t be.’” Turns out, it was. But Tsai isn’t just a reality star — she’s an illustrator who has worked with Starbucks Japan and most recently, she’s dipping her toes into the fashion world. Head to WWD.com to read about her time on the show, modeling and her art. #wwdeye (📷: @danieldorsa)
More changes are coming to New York Fashion Week: Beginning with the spring 2019 collection, @alexanderwangny will move his New York show to June from September, adopting a biannual schedule with collections shown in June and December. Additionally, the @cfda is planning for an official summer/winter fashion season taking place as soon as June and December 2018. Read more about the upcoming changes on WWD.com. #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @slovekinpics)