Instead of basking in the fact that Lululemon posted a 48.8 percent jump in fourth-quarter profits on a 30.7 percent gain in revenues, a “disappointed” Day told analysts and investors that she expected the recall would cut first-quarter revenues by $12 million to $17 million. The firm’s lost revenues are projected at $45 million and $50 million for the balance of the year. Day said the Vancouver-based firm anticipates writing off yoga pants that have yet to be delivered for the summer.
The March 1 recall of black pants made from Lululemon’s proprietary technical Luon fabric impacted about 17 percent of its women’s bottoms.
“I think our first step is to see what is correct or what we can use….Meanwhile, we are working with our suppliers to do some additional testing of any old stock that we have,” said Day, who noted that the second quarter would be the “most impacted,” with same-store gains in the low-single digits or “close to flat.”
For the fourth quarter ended Feb. 3, Lululemon posted net income of $109.4 million, or 75 cents a diluted share, compared with year-ago income of $73.5 million, or 51 cents. Revenues rose to $485.5 million from $371.5 million a year earlier. The brand beat Wall Street’s estimates of 74 cents a share on sales of $482.1 million.
The retailer now expects first-quarter earnings per share of between 28 cents and 30 cents. Wall Street was looking for 40 cents.
On the earnings call, analysts wondered if the issue could have been avoided by stricter quality-control guidelines set by Lululemon’s network of factories. For nearly a decade, the yoga-inspired brand has used Taiwanese supplier Eclat Textile Co., which, according to news reports, defended its manufacturing process earlier this week.
The shipments went through a “certification process which Lululemon had approved,” Eclat’s chief financial officer Roger Lo told The Wall Street Journal, adding the pants were manufactured “according to the requirements” in its contract with the brand.
Day, who didn’t cast any direct blame, said: “The truth of the matter is that the only way that you can actually test for the issue is to put the pants on and bend over. So, just putting the pants on themselves doesn’t solve the problem. Because it passed all of the basic metric tests and the hand feel is relatively the same. It was very difficult for the factories to isolate the issue and it wasn’t until we got into the store and started putting it on people that we could actually see the issue.”
She offered that the Canadian brand is “holding” all the impacted products because there may be “some treatment solutions” that could solve of the problems.
Lululemon said it has made “significant investments” in regulating dye issues, a problem that Mark Sunderland, a professor of textile engineering and resident expert at Philadelphia University called “common” among activewear brands.
According to Sunderland, it may be difficult for Lululemon to pinpoint whether the problem is caused by dye, fit, finishing or knitting errors, among others.
Either way, the professor said the sheerness problem isn’t an isolated incident, as countless consumers have been complaining on the Lululemon’s Web site for nearly six months about the subpar quality of the black Luon bottoms.
“This has been happening for a while,” he said, dubbing Lululemon’s call to action “surreptitious” as it coincides with financial reporting.
Sunderland said he’s noticed a decline in Lululemon’s quality over the last two years, and said the company probably believed “by changing something” it could keep “profit margins high” without the consumer detecting anything. The problem is that the Lululemon customer is “extremely savvy,” and notices when changes have been made, Sunderland noted.
“They are really looking at the quality of the product versus the money they are spending,” he said of the typical Lululemon customer, who is willing to fork over $100 for a pair of exercise pants.
“Lululemon is a very active company and their customers are very loyal and very outspoken,” Sunderland said. “Lululemon tells its story very well on social media.”
It’s on social media sites where Lululemon’s cult-like following has grown, and it’s also where they converse about their favorite brand. Perhaps an outpouring of negative comments on those sites pushed the firm to finally react, wondered the professor.
“I do still think Lululemon has a lot of brand loyalty,” Sunderland offered. “Their client base may help lift them out of this if they play their cards right.”
"'Dynasty' is all about gowns, the diamonds and the scandal, so it's a bit like the fashion industry. When we come to Cannes it's all about the red carpet dresses too, so it all fit really well," said designer @philippplein78 on the theme of his high-glamour resort 2019 show at his mansion in Cannes. #wwdfashion #cannes (📷: @zefashioninsider)
"I think Spike is such a brilliant director because he holds up a mirror to society and reflects these issues, yet he doesn't shove it down your throat, he doesn't tell you what to think," says @lauraharrier on her latest film @Blackkklansman. Harrier was at the Cannes Film Festival – for the very first time – with @officialspikelee. #wwdeye #cannes (📷: @zefashioninsider)
“I would think to myself, Are you happy? Yes, I’m wildly happy. I go to this studio every day and, in my inside voices, I’m giggling; I’m singing. Yes, it’s a lot of work, it’s a [huge] volume of material. It wouldn’t be for everybody. But I was very happy,” said soap opera star @therealsusanlucci of checking in throughout the years with her career trajectory. Lucci spoke to WWD about her decades-long career, love for pilates, motherhood and her QVC activewear line. Read Bridget Foley’s full piece on Lucci on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: @celestesloman)
@balmain has taken a stand at the #cannes Film Festival, dressing 16 actresses at a press call for the project “Noire N’est Pas Mon Metier,” or “Black Is Not My Profession.” The multimedia project includes a book, photo exhibit and documentary, which aims to expose discrimination in the French and American entertainment industries. “The moment I was asked to participate, I knew it was right for me, and for this brand, to form a part of this moment,” Balmain creative director @olivier_rousteing told WWD. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
"I always feel curious and I feel like there's more to learn. But I think being relevant, feeling relevant, I personally always feel that there's just so much more to know. And maybe that's the key.” — @themarcjacobs #wwdsummits #wwdbeauty (📷: @patrickmacleodphoto )
“The most amazing thing about her is that, regardless of all the things that have happened to her, her spirit is so undaunted by all of it. She is the most cheerful person you will ever meet. She doesn’t see problems, she only sees solutions,” said @ajanaomi_king of activist Ifrah Ahmed, who she plays in a new film “A Girl from Mogadishu.” WWD caught up with King at Cannes — Head to WWD.com to read more about her new role, personal style and how she uses social media for causes like Time’s Up and Black Lives Matter #wwdeye
WWD asked a number designers to share their thoughts on what Meghan Markle’s wedding gown will look like this Saturday. Here, Valentino’s Pierpaolo Piccioli sketches his look. #wwdfashion #royalwedding #meghanmarkle