NEW YORK — Nine months after Elie Tahari filed a lawsuit against Andrew Rosen, his former business partner in Theory, the case has been decided overwhelmingly in Rosen's favor.
Justice Helen E. Freedman, of New York State Supreme Court, dismissed six claims related to the sale of Theory, but granted one that involves royalties Tahari claimed he is owed for the sale of Theory clothing in Asia.
Besides Rosen, the defendants included Ricky C. Sasaki, Link International, Link Theory Holdings Co., Fast Retailing Co. and L&F Holdings.
In September, Tahari filed a lawsuit seeking no less than $180 million in damages from Rosen and nine other defendants, alleging "commercial treachery and fraudulent self-dealing." In the suit, Tahari charged Rosen defrauded him into selling Theory at a price that didn't reflect the U.S. company's true value. Further, the suit alleged the new Japanese owners resold Theory in an initial public offering on the Tokyo Stock Exchange in 2005 at a market capitalization of more than $500 million — nearly five times the sale price of Theory LLC less than two years before. Tahari sought to recover half of the $500 million market capitalization of Link Theory Holdings in 2005, minus the amount that he received for his interest in Theory in 2003, as well as royalty payments.
In 2003, when Tahari agreed to sell his interest in Theory to an acquiring entity created by Link International, Fast Retailing and L&F Holdings, Tahari received approximately $53 million, according to the suit. Rosen sold his one-half interest for about $49 million, together with 11 percent of L&F Holdings, which held the U.S. operations of Theory.
Dismissing the six causes of action, the judge ruled that "allegations that consist of bare legal conclusions or that are flatly contradicted by documentary evidence or are inherently incredible are not entitled to such consideration." The legal filing states that theories in which Tahari sought to recover the proceeds of Link Theory Holding's public offering "are either contradicted by the relevant contracts or are purely speculative and conclusory."
According to the court documents, the crux of the defendants' position "is that this is a ‘classic case of seller's remorse' for which Tahari has suffered no cognizable injury.""The fact that all material information was disclosed in the purchase agreement and accompanying documents belies Tahari's claim that he reasonably relied on Rosen's oral statements and was defrauded into selling his interest. In any event, Tahari is not entitled to the damages he seeks, a portion of the market capitalization of LTH in 2005, because Tahari received full compensation for his interest in Theory," according to the legal documents.
Furthermore, the ruling states, "It is also speculative to assume that had Tahari not sold his interest, he could have expanded Theory himself, convinced Rosen to continue to work for him or hired a comparable replacement to manage Theory, commenced an initial public offering, and realized the same amount from a public sale as did the owners of LTH. Thus, Tahari cannot demonstrate reasonable reliance or an actual out-of-pocket injury and the fraud case is dismissed," according to the ruling.
The document states that at the time of the sale, "Rosen's and Tahari's financial interests were aligned. If the $100 million sale price of Theory understated the value of the company, then Rosen and Tahari would have been equally harmed.…There is no indication that Rosen concealed specific financial information relevant to the valuation of Theory or that Rosen prevented Tahari from discovering relevant information or obtaining an independent appraisal."
The ruling noted that Tahari and Rosen hired separate counsel to represent them in the sale of Theory "and Tahari had a duty to review the documents."
"Thus, the fact that all relevant information was disclosed to Tahari and that he had an opportunity to perform an independent investigation bars the breach of fiduciary duty and negligence claims, and those claims are dismissed," according to the decision.
However, the judge upheld the seventh cause of action for breach of contract. In the suit, Tahari contended the defendants "colluded to conceal the actual royalty obligations owed to Tahari for the sale of Theory clothing by underreporting Theory sales in Asia, and that they breached the Purchase Agreement by refusing to cooperate with his demands to produce books and records reflecting royalty obligations."
In her decision, the judge wrote, "Tahari's cross motion is granted only to the extent that the remaining defendants are directed to furnish documents related to the obligation to pay royalties." The remaining defendants (LTH, LTH U.S. and Fast Retailing) have 20 days to respond.Reached for comment Monday, Rosen told WWD, "I expected a good result from this, and we couldn't be happier with the way it came out. The work we did in building the company, I couldn't understand how this all came about and why it came about.
"When Elie filed the lawsuit last September, I was shocked. I never saw it coming and didn't understand why, so the judge's decision is a good thing," continued Rosen. "It's good to have this behind us with this kind of result. I think we'll move on from here. It was unfortunate that Elie would take that kind of position. I feel it's important that the truth of the whole thing came out in the end. When someone is making accusations against myself, the Japanese people and the company, I didn't feel good about it. I do feel the judge's ruling was very satisfying."
In a statement, Tahari said, "I am pleased and grateful that the core and backbone claim which we made against my former, disloyal business associates has been sustained. We look forward to a thorough and careful evidentiary discovery where our claim and damages will be substantially amplified. In the meantime, we believe that the mistakes and conduct of those involved will become ever more visible."
“My personal philosophy to beauty is paying attention to oneself. I love to be outdoors, lots of fresh air, trying to take care of yourself as best you can. I always notice that comes through,” says Felicity Jones, the global face of @shiseido-owned @cledepeaubeauteus, which launches today. Head to WWD.com to read more about the actress’ love for beauty and how she prepared for her new role in “The Basis of Sex,” playing the young Ruth Bader Ginsburg. #wwdbeauty (📷: @dandoperalski)
For men’s fall 2018, @giuseppezanotti drew on elements from streetwear, sport, biker, combat and rock ‘n’ roll. Pictured here are a pair of shoes from the collection, featuring zippers, rhinestones, and silver hardware. Head to WWD.com to see a roundup of the accessories from Milan’s men’s fall 2018 shows. #wwdfashion (📷: Andrea Delb)
To celebrate the 25th anniversary of @ralphlauren’s snowboarding collection, the brand is mining its archives. The iconic brand is reintroducing vintage styles and dropping new designs for a color capsule that will be available in Ralph Lauren stores and @openingceremony on January 25. The capsule will consist of 10 pieces, including the Snow Beach Pullover, pictured here, which is a collector’s item that rapper Raekwon wore in Wu-Tang Clan’s “Can It Be All So Simple” video. #wwdfashion (📷: Tom Gould)
For @rochasofficial’s pre-fall 2018 collection, creative director Alessandro Dell’Acqua channeled the sophisticated and intriguing Catherine Denevue in the film “Belle de Jour.” Polished collarless coats, midi skirts, suits and ’60s graphic motifs were all featured in the collection, adding a sense of discreet luxury. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdfashion
“We tried to produce clothing of that couture quality, but the most daunting part was that we only had a matter of days [to do it],” said costume designer Lou Eyrich, who recreated Gianni Versace’s iconic looks for @americancrimestoryfx. Eyrich searched online retailers and vintage shops for original pieces from the design house and for @penelopecruzoficial, who plays Donatella Versace. Head to WWD.com to read how she created the Versace world. #wwdfashion
Only three months after her stellar debut catwalk season, @kaiagerber has inked her first big design collaboration –– with @karllagerfeld. The collection blends Lagerfeld’s Parisian chic aesthetic and the model’s signature West Coast casual style via RTW, accessories, footwear and more. The #KarlLagerfeldxKaia collection will launch in September with a series of events. Get all the details on WWD.com. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
Harrods plans to remove the famous statue of Princess Diana and Dodi Al Fayed from the bottom of the Egyptian escalators and hand it back to Mohamed Al-Fayed. “We are very proud to have played our role in celebrating the lives of Diana, Princess of Wales and Dodi Al Fayed at Harrods and to have welcomed people from around the world to visit the memorial for the past 20 years,” said Michael Ward, Harrods managing director. “With the announcement of the new official memorial statue to Diana, Princess of Wales at Kensington Palace, we feel that the time is right to return this memorial to Mr. Al Fayed and for the public to be invited to pay their respects at the palace.” More on the news, with reporting by @loreleimarfil, at WWD.com. #wwdnews