J.C. Penney Co. Inc. chairman and chief executive officer Myron E. “Mike” Ullman 3rd and the rest of its board sent a missile back to activist investor William Ackman on Monday by adopting a shareholder rights plan, or poison pill, that would make it prohibitively expensive for anyone to take over the retailer without the consent of the board.
So far, Ackman, ceo of Pershing Square Capital Management, hasn’t expressed an interest in acquiring the whole company. But the investor has taken a 16.5 percent stake in the Plano, Tex.-based Penney’s and said he wants to meet with management about operations and strategy. He’s working with Vornado Realty Trust, which owns another 9.9 percent of the retailer.
If Ackman ups his stake or if anyone else hits the 10 percent mark, the rest of the shareholders would get the opportunity to buy a portion of a preferred share of the company for $130. The effect would be to lessen the stake of the would-be acquirer, who can’t participate in the plan, and to jack up the overall price tag by astronomical proportions.
The company’s shares fell 57 cents, or 1.7 percent, to close at $33.30 in New York Stock Exchange trading Monday.
“It effectively dilutes the acquirer out of the picture,” Douglas Hand, attorney at Hand Baldachin & Amburgey, who has worked on both sides of hostile takeovers but is not involved in the Penney’s battle, said of the poison pill. “The acquirer really must deal with the board. They’re doing what they can to have the conversation occur with the board and to be in control of that process.”
With a poison pill in place, Ackman can no longer simply offer to buy shares from other stockholders and gain control at the firm. He would have to come up with an offer that was sweet enough to get the board to remove the poison pill.
“What management appears to be doing is taking a very defensive, crouched position,” said Craig Johnson, consultant and president of Customer Growth Partners. “I would love to see J.C. Penney put as much energy into reviving its core business. Companies that put in poison pills most typically have done so to protect entrenched management.”
Johnson said the company has been on the wane and trying to stem the market share losses with new deals and collaborations, such as MNG by Mango shop-in-shops and a new Liz Claiborne exclusive.
Ackman is seen as a savvy player who is not afraid to take his case directly to shareholders or to try to oust boards. He made repeated and public appeals for change at Target Corp. and spent $10 million in an unsuccessful attempt to place five directors on the retailer’s board last year.
Penney’s is more vulnerable than Target was since its 12 directors serve one-year terms ending at the annual meeting next spring. And as part of a bloc controlling more than 26 percent of the company, Ackman is in a stronger position, making him a potentially more potent force when it comes to shaking up the board.
The investor has been generally quiet on his plans for Penney’s, though he appears to think the retailer could do more to cut expenses. Ackman could not be reached for comment Monday and Penney’s declined to elaborate on any interactions with the investor.
@beyonce chose a custom gown by @falgunishanepeacockindia for mother @mstinalawson 's second annual Wearable Art Gala last night. The gown, which took 10 days to make, was inspired by Nubian warrior queen Amanishakheto. Reporting by @hernameislex . #wwdeye 👑 🐝#beyonce
After dressing @justintimberlake for his Super Bowl halftime performance last month, @stellamccartney has designed the star’s "Man of the Woods" tour wardrobe. Timberlake will be wearing a mix of pieces from McCartney’s fall men's collection as well as custom designs and items from his own closet. #wwdfashion
@carmeloanthony is upping his fashion game once again, introducing a hat collection with @goorinbros. Called Fresh Greens by Melo x Goorin, the line consists of five unisex models, all of which are made in America from 100 percent wool. Each hat is lined with Anthony’s signature and the inscription “Knowledge of self, wisdom and understanding.” You can purchase the collection line at Goorin’s website as well as three off its stores in San Francisco, New York City and Las Vegas #wwdaccessories
“I am of tradition, but that doesn’t mean I have an old outlook on life,” Hubert de Givenchy told WWD in an interview in 1978. The legendary designer, who died last week at the age of 91, achieved wide success soon after launching his own couture boutique in the early ’50s, but he refused to pine for that time. For the first time since its original publication, read our interview with Givenchy on his awe for Audrey Hepburn and looking forward. Link in bio. #wwdarchives #fbf (📷: Pierre Schermann)
About last night: @alexachung and @supergausa toasted the launch of their capsule collection. “It’s the shape that I love, so rather than amend the last and make the sole crazy or do anything wild, we just did really subtle additions that I think make it look really luxe-y,” said Chung. #wwdfashion (📷: Marc Patrick)
Exclusive: @off____white’s @virgilabloh is launching an exclusive eyewear capsule collection @sunglasshut. The unisex collection, which is made up of three styles, first made its debut on the brand’s fall runway show in Paris. Get all the details on WWD.com – link in bio. #wwdnews #wwdfashion