NEW YORK — Coach Inc.'s $1 million trade dress lawsuit against Target Corp. was rebuffed by the mass retailer Tuesday.
In a brief statement, the retailer said, "Target has procedures in place to ensure that we do not sell counterfeit products to our guests. We have been assured that the Coach product showcased in our store is authentic, therefore we believe the lawsuit is without merit."
The case, filed last Friday in federal court here, alleged that Target sold a counterfeit Coach handbag at a Target store in Largo, Fla. The 49-page filing alleged that the handbag in question "bears a counterfeit of at least one of the Coach trademarks" and that the retailer "never made an inquiry of Coach concerning the genuineness of any item bearing a Coach trademark."
Industry observers said the lawsuit is one of several in recent months that show growing friction between retailers and brand owners, who have stepped up efforts to protect their trademarks.
There are a number of factors that come into play with the increased number of brands suing large national retailers, said Harley Lewin, chairman of trademarks and global brand strategies for the intellectual property practice of Greenberg Traurig.
In the past, brand owners have been reluctant to sue retailers, not wanting to bite the hand that feeds them, Lewin and other legal experts said. That does not come into play with every brand and every retailer, but it is a factor in considering whether or not to litigate. Other factors include a party's willingness to respond to cease-and-desist letters or the possibility of working with a brand to address a problem outside of the courts.
In some cases, gray-market goods, legitimate branded goods intended for sale in other markets that find their way into the U.S. through channels not authorized by a brand, further complicate the situation. The real clash, Lewin said, is driven by the strategic shift of midprice retailers, such as Target, who try and draw in a higher-end consumer.
"The real reason that you're seeing more of it, aside from all of the considerations that go into anybody making a litigation decision, is that the likelihood of these companies carrying bogus product has gone up because of their own strategic changes," Lewin said.
"I think that all anyone really wants in life is to have people understand us for who we actually are, despite everything," says Ruth Negga. The actress talks "Preachers" season 2 and more on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: Dan Doperalski)
"That's something that resonates with me too because I'm so locked into a number. If I go over that number it completely ruins my day so it's nice to get detached from the number on the scale." - Chelsea Handler on Kelly LeVeque's book "Body Love." #wwdeye (📷: John Salangsang)