SHANGHAI — China’s State Food and Drug Administration, or SFDA, has released a draft proposal approving the use of alternatives to animal testing for cosmetics.
This is the first time the SFDA, which oversees the testing and registration of all domestically and internationally produced cosmetics on sale in China, has seriously considered changing its regulations to allow non-animal testing alternatives for cosmetics.
The proposal is under review while the SFDA consults with interested parties, one of whom is Professor Zhao Hua, who is head of the China Cosmetics Research Center, or CCRC, at Beijing Technology and Business University.
“With the fast development of the economy, animal welfare and protection are becoming more popular,” he said, adding that the SFDA has already undertaken considerable research over the past 12 months into testing alternatives.
April Guo, head of the Chemical Inspection and Regulation Service’s cosmetic registration and cosmetic ingredient assessment team in China, is confident non-animal testing alternatives will eventually be implemented. “On the 10th of February, the SFDA issued a notice saying an alternative method is being explored, but we don’t know when it will come into force and the SFDA has always said that it will take a long time to use primarily alternative testing methods in China,” Guo said.
International cosmetic brands who want to import their products into China have to undergo stringent registration and licensing procedures, often using a company such as Guo’s CIRS to help them navigate China’s intricacies and bureaucracy. Any ingredient that has not previously been made available on the Chinese market is required to undergo a number of tests before it is licensed, including some conducted on animals.
This regulation has become problematic for some international companies, which had previously committed to abandoning animal testing, but must now allow animal testing to gain access to the massive Chinese cosmetics market. Animal testing in China has recently become a hot-button issue in the U.S., where a class action lawsuit was filed in the central district of California on Feb. 28 against the Estée Lauder Cos., Inc., Avon Products Inc. and Mary Kay Inc.
International experts in the field of animal research, such as Anthony James, who is head of the Laboratory Animal Services Centre at the Chinese University of Hong Kong, believe that regulations based on a utilitarian model of cost-benefit analysis should be adopted by China, in order to bring the country in line with international practices. “Cosmetics are by and large not a medical product saving lives. It’s not a need, it’s a want. There has to be a higher bar set for animal testing for cosmetics and it shouldn’t be permissible at all where there are alternatives,” he added.
Alternative testing methods are becoming increasingly accurate and the 3T3 NRU phototoxicity test method, the method currently being considered by the SFDA, is already widely accepted internationally.
It has become an issue in China with the emergence of widespread media campaigns that decry animal cruelty in traditional medicine and popular food, including shark’s fin soup.
However, James Roy, a senior analyst at China Market Research Group, said, “It’s an issue that has quite low awareness among Chinese consumers. Animal protection and related issues aren’t one of the main things that comes into Chinese consumers’ minds when they’re buying cosmetics,” Roy said, citing product safety as the number-one concern for consumers in a country constantly plagued by safety scandals.
As with many things in China, economic concerns, rather than moral ones, are likely to be the driver for change. One particularly pressing concern for China’s cosmetics industry is the European Commission’s Cosmetics Directive, which aims to phase out animal testing for all cosmetic products on sale in the European Union. Like products from other countries, Chinese-made cosmetics that are tested on animals will be banned for sale in the EU as of March 2013.
“I think this is the big challenge for Chinese manufacturers and this is why the SFDA is under a lot of pressure to handle this situation,” Guo said.
There also is pressure being applied by the California lawsuit, which alleges that Lauder, Avon and Mary Kay resumed animal testing of cosmetics in order to enter the Chinese market, despite claiming in the U.S. that their products are “cruelty free.”
Plaintiffs Marina Beltran, Maria Rodriguez, Janna Herrera, Jenna Anderlie and Trasse Faria are suing the cosmetics companies for fraud, unfair business practices, false advertising and violations of California’s consumers legal remedies act. They are seeking injunctive relief and also looking for $100 million in damages, not to mention punitive damages and other compensation.
Lauder stoutly defended its policies. “More than 20 years ago, we were one of the first companies to end animal testing to substantiate the safety of our products,” a Lauder spokeswoman told WWD in response to the lawsuit. “It is important that we share with you that our commitment to end animal testing everywhere has not changed. Our products are not tested on animals except when absolutely mandated by law. We are committed to the universal acceptance of non-animal test methods with the goal of eliminating animal testing. We will continue to invest in scientific research to promote acceptance of non-animal test methods by authorities around the world.”
Taking the final spot on the mens’ portion of New York Fashion Week calendar next month will be none other than @tomford. Though he’s shown his men’s wear in New York in the past, this will mark the first time the designer has shown his men’s collection alone during New York Fashion Week: Men’s. His runway show will debut on February 6 at the Park Avenue Armory. #wwdfashion
London-based couture house @ralphandrusso has certainly been in the spotlight, having its dresses worn by @beyonce, Angelina Jolie, Meghan Markle in her engagement photos and more. For couture, Tamara Ralph focused on ornamentation — think: feathers with chain mail, jet embroidery and clusters of pearls and crystals. See the rest of the collection on WWD.com #wwdfashion #couture (📷: @giovanni_giannoni_photo)
Minnie Mouse celebrated her 90th birthday by getting her own star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. For her celebratory luncheon, @coach’s creative director @stuartvevers dressed her in a custom made prairie dress, complete with Vever’s take on the polka dot – black sequined versions – under a cropped motorcycle jacket. The designer also put his own mark on Minnie’s classic red shoes, infusing the color with sparkles and adding some Coach crystals. “We chose colors that were very Minnie and also represented quintessential Coach elements,” said Vevers. #wwdfashion #nationalpolkadotday (📷: George Chinsee)
@nickjonas is unveiling his first-ever apparel collection through a partnership with John Varvatos. The limited-edition capsule, which makes its debut in spring, also marks the first time the designer has collaborated with anyone on a line. “The process in working with Nick is amazing. It’s inspiring to be around someone who is not only connected with the trade that they do, but also with what’s happening in the environment around him, and how that connects to what we do with style,” said Varvatos. (RG: @johnvarvatos) #wwdfashion
@margotrobbie steps out onto the red carpet wearing @miumiu. The actress is nominated for “Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role” in “I, Tonya” at the #SagAwards. (📷: Stewart Cook) #wwdfashion
For @massimogiorgetti of @msgm, the Nineties are his favorite decade. “They had a huge impact on my personal growth. What I like of the Nineties is that they are not so precise in terms of style as other decades…there was actually a bit of everything,” he said. As seen on MSGM’s Spring 2018 show: tie-dye and a bit of grunge, two styles that are synonymous with the decade #wwdfashion #wwddecades (📷: @kukukuba)