WASHINGTON — China agreed to eliminate a dozen export and import subsidies by Jan. 1, settling a U.S. trade case but potentially increasing costs for apparel importers.
The U.S. brought the World Trade Organization trade case against China in February, charging Chinese companies with foreign investment received tax breaks that broke global trade rules. Mexico later joined the case against China.
Hailed as a victory for the Bush administration, the settlement reached Thursday could help ease tensions ahead of high-level economic talks between the two countries next month and reduce pressure on Capitol Hill to crack down on the country in the face of a growing trade deficit. The U.S. deficit with China weighed in at a record $232 billion last year.
"This case was about standing up for American manufacturers and workers," U.S. Trade Representative Susan Schwab said at a press conference detailing the settlement. "The Chinese government has been slow to emerge from its historical role controlling the economy. We have been urging China to eliminate all industrial polices, like these prohibited subsidies, which interfere so fundamentally with market-driven economic and trade outcome."
The subsidies distorted trade either by encouraging exports or offering incentives to buy Chinese-made goods, thus making it harder for American companies to compete, she said.
Export subsidies included tax benefits that could help up to 60 percent of the country's shipments abroad. For example, Chinese companies with foreign investment that exported more than 70 percent of their products could get their tax rate cut in half.
The impact of the action is unclear, given a lack of transparency in the autocratic Chinese system.
"These are the subsidies that we have been able to identify that are clearly prohibited by the WTO," said Schwab. "We do not currently see any WTO-prohibited subsidies...that we would need to go after."
Some of the remaining government subsidies, while not violating WTO rules, are still subject to countervailing duty trade cases from the Commerce Department if they run afoul of U.S. import laws. U.S. textile companies, however, can't bring such cases on apparel because they require that a company makes a competing product.Gary Hufbauer, a senior fellow at the Petersen Institute for International Economics, said the positive move will quiet the critics who claim China "doesn't play fair.
"The second angle, which is probably just as equally important, is it gives Treasury Secretary [Henry] Paulson Jr., Schwab and Commerce Secretary Carlos Gutierrez, who are the chief lobbyists on this issue, a leg up with lawmakers to say 'diplomacy works,'" Hufbauer said.
Though good news for U.S. manufacturers that complain their Chinese counterparts have an unfair advantage, the settlement does not end the subsidy issue in their eyes.
"It's a good step," said Cass Johnson, president of the National Council of Textile Organizations. "It's one of many steps that need to be taken. The government has begun to peel the onion on how the Chinese government subsidizes their industry."
But importers said the settlement could hurt them by raising costs.
"The assumption is as they eliminate subsidies, that will make costs in China go up," said Stephen Lamar, executive vice president of the American Apparel & Footwear Association. "There are a lot of things that still make people want to source in China. On balance, people are still going to want to source in China."
On Capitol Hill, the political implication for pending China legislation was difficult to gauge. Lawmakers appeared resolute in their drive to impose punitive duties on Chinese imports if the country does not raise the value of its currency.
"The most critical problem in relation to Chinese subsidies is domestic subsidies, not export subsidies," Rep. Sander Levin (D., Mich.), chairman of the House trade subcommittee, said in a statement. "We need a comprehensive trade policy toward China requiring action on piracy, import safety, dumping and currency manipulation."
Sen. Max Baucus (D., Mont.), chairman of the Senate Finance Committee and co-sponsor of a currency bill, indicated he also plans to keep up the pressure on China.
"I look forward to continued success in abolishing China's other unfair trading practices without delay," Baucus said in a statement.
Democratic leaders, who contend the undervalued currency gives Chinese exports an unfair advantage against the U.S., have said they plan to take up currency legislation next year.
Exclusive: Nicola Formichetti is parting ways with @diesel after nearly four years. Formichetti, who served as Lady Gaga’s stylist in 2009, joined Diesel in 2013 as creative and artistic director. His first show debuted in Venice with a show held at the Venetian Arsenal. #wwdfashion #wwdnews
The polo shirt - an icon of preppy style - is roaring back into fashion in many creative guises, like this A-line polyester top from @carven, worn with @31philliplim cotton and elastane pants. Designers stretched a fashion classic into all kinds of new permutations this season. See how @mayteallende styled the preppy trend on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📸 : Kinya)
(Market Editors: @andrew_shang and @elmercer, Makeup: @amandawilsonmakeup using @fentybeauty, Hair: @gonn24, Model: @bara_holotova at @women360mgmt)
“I do like period [projects] a lot because I like creating those worlds, a world that is different from today," costume designer Mark Bridges said about the '50s British couture featured in @phantomthread. Bridges created the overall aesthetic and individual fashion looks for the film, which stars Daniel Day-Lewis, Lesley Manville and Vicky Krieps. Pictured here is a gown he designed for Krieps who plays Alma – the love interest of Day-Lewis' character, Reynolds Woodcock. #wwdfashion
@prada is embracing the holiday season with a series of short movies about the art of gift-giving. "The Postman's Gifts", which was directed by American filmmaker Autumn de Wilde, focuses on the brand's signature Prada Galleria bag and features Elijah Wood as the postman. In the first two episodes, Wood's delivers the iconic bag to @emmaroberts, who plays herself as a movie star, and Sasha Frolova. #wwdfashion
“I think I never met the person while we were working,” Vicky Krieps said of Daniel Day-Lewis, who she plays the love interest of in “Phantom Thread.” Day-Lewis remained perennially in character, so much so that she feels she’s just meeting him now. “It’s interesting to see how different he is in real life to the character,” Krieps said. WWD sat down with the 34-year-old actress to talk about her new role in the period film, which brings the fifties’ gender dynamics into the mix. Read more on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @lexieblacklock)
@gucci has expanded its “Places” project to include six new cities. The initiative, which was first unveiled in July, aims to invite people to explore inspirational locations for the brand. On the list is the Biblioteca Angelica library in Rome pictured here. See the other five new venues on WWD.com. #wwdfashion (📷: @massimo_listri_official)
#ad From tools to lashes, WWD rounded up wellness and beauty products guaranteed to take your skin care and makeup routines to the next level in 2018. Follow along as @laceandleatherbyelyse, @ashnfashn and @elleisalwayshere experiment with these products on their Instagram profiles and blogs. #NewYearBetterYou
Blogger @camilacoelho is one of the fastest growing beauty influencers around the world. The bilingual blogger has worked with brands like @revolve Beauty, @dior, @louisvuitton and more and has an Earned Media Value of $34,338,441, according to @tribedynamics. But Coelho isn’t the only influencer making a major impact — head to WWD.com to see the other fastest-growing influencers in six key global markets. #beautyfridays (📷: @zefashioninsider)