MILAN — Guccio Gucci SpA said Monday that it has appealed an Italian court’s decision that rejected its claim that Guess Inc. violated several of its “iconic” trademarks.
“The appeal is a necessary action to protect its extraordinary historic wealth of iconic distinctive signs, famous the world over and, more generally, to protect the values of creativity and innovation of quality of Made in Italy products,” Gucci said.
Last year, Gucci won a qualified victory against Guess in a Manhattan federal court in a suit that claimed some of Guess’ designs and logos were directly inspired by Gucci’s collections. While the court ruled in its favor, Gucci was awarded only $4.7 million in damages, a fraction of the upward of $221 million it sought. RELATED STORY: Guess Wins Gucci Suit in Italy >>
In May, a Milan court ruled that Guess’s Quattro G-diamond pattern is not related to Gucci’s interlocking double-G pattern. The verdict also declared the diamond-patterned G logo and Flora pattern trademarks, previously registered by Gucci in Italy and the European Union, null and void.
With regard to losing the battle on home turf, Gucci called the Milan court’s decision taken in May “surprisingly negative” and said that it is challenging such a decision and requesting a reversal of the ruling, which also subsequently canceled three logos Gucci registered for Italy and the European Community.
Gucci said that it has made several attempts to resolve the issue with Guess Inc. out of the courtroom.
“The seriousness and broadness of the violations of which Guess is accused, together with its unavailability to find a serious, reasonable solution, have rendered our attempts to settle the case out of court futile,” Gucci said.
Gucci’s comments contradict an earlier statement made by Paul Marciano, chief executive officer of Guess. “In my opinion, the three-year battle in New York and four years in Milan was a result of massive and unnecessary litigation that should have been easily resolved with a simple phone call, which Gucci never made,” Marciano said.
Commenting on Gucci’s appeal while in Florence, Marciano said, “After the 83-page ruling with a three-judge panel in Milan and reviewing the findings, we feel very confident in our facts. We will address Gucci’s appeal in our reply briefs. Gucci executives in the U.S. misled the court and we see similar facts in the Milan court. We will wait for the final outcome.”
A Gucci spokesperson said that Gucci’s other suits against Guess in both China and France are ongoing.
Fondazione Altagamma, the Italian association of luxury goods companies, has assisted Italian luxury goods companies like Gucci in similar cases since the early Nineties.
Aside from intellectual property and unfair competition issues, Italian luxury leaders are battling rising tariffs, trade restrictions and an onslaught of counterfeit goods that obtain a ticket into Italy and the rest of the EU through the Internet and international postal services, said Armando Branchini, vice chairman of Fondazione Altagamma and executive team president of the European Cultural and Creative Industries Alliance.
Ridding the world of counterfeit goods and the presence of tariff and non-tariff barriers, would help lift the global value of luxury goods consumption and employment by about 30 to 35 percent, Branchini added.
Assouline is paying homage to the late Azzedine Alaïa with a reprint of "Alaïa Livre de Collection.” The book is comprised of photographs of the designer's summer 1992 runway show with models Christy Turlington Burns, Naomi Campbell and Tyra Banks, pictured here at right. #wwdfashion #alaia #tyrabanks
Fall 2018 accessories take on a painterly hue, with Nebulas Blue among Pantone’s top 10 colors of the season. (📸: @jonghyupstudio ; editor: @twallz21 ; stylist and set designer: @haideefindlaylevin ) #wwdaccessories
@americanapparelusa is relaunching the brand outside of the U.S. today, opening its online store to more than 200 countries. The company is also contemplating a return to brick-and-mortar, though details have not been confirmed. In tandem with the expanded distribution is a recasting of a social media ad campagn, called “Back to Basics,” pictured here, with a focus on diversity and a cast of models above the age of 21. Read more on WWD.com #wwdnews #wwdfashion
Exclusive: @britneyspears is continuing to expand her brand. The pop icon, who appears in @kenzo ’s latest campaign, is partnering with Epic Rights to launch a line of branded merchandise. Read @hernameislex ‘s story, link in bio. #wwdnews #britneyspears
The Duchess of Cambridge channeled Princess Diana’s look upon giving birth to Prince Harry, when she and the Duke of Cambridge departed the hospital with the new baby Prince this afternoon in London. #wwdeye #princeofcambridge
The new Prince of Cambridge has arrived! The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge posed with the 8-pound newborn. She wore a look from one of her go-to designers, @jennypackham. Tap link in bio for more. #wwdeye #princeofcambridge
Jewelry label @alisonlou has made a name for itself with fine jewelry that speaks to the Millennial market. Now @twallz21 reports that the label is bringing those playful ideas to a new affordable line of lucite hoops with the launch of Loucite by Alison Lou. Here’s a look from the line modeled by @emrata. #wwdaccessories
@sarahjessicaparker and @gilt are teaming up on a bridal ready-to-wear line. Tomorrow, Parker will launch SJP by Sarah Jessica Parker Bridal — and as part of the launch, Gilt will offer 15 exclusive styles from the SJP by Sarah Jessica Parker footwear collection that were designed to complement the new line. Made out of 10 styles, the line is designed for a variety of occasions, from bridal showers to receptions. Get more details on WWD.com #wwdfashion