The case, which was filed in Manhattan federal court in 2009, is centered on the notion that Guess — along with handbag licensee Signal Products Inc. and footwear licensee Marc Fisher Footwear — knocked off Gucci product, including goods that featured the brand’s diamond-shaped logoed pattern, square “G” design, a signature script and tri-striped motif. Gucci is looking for damages of $221 million and injunctive relief.
Clad in a black suit, white button-down shirt and black striped tie, Marciano, who testified two weeks earlier, seemed gratified by the rousing closing argument made by his attorney, Daniel Petrocelli of O’Melveny & Myers LLP.
Petrocelli, who is known for his work in the wrongful death civil suit against O.J. Simpson and for representing Enron ceo Jeffrey Skilling, had, until this point, appeared more subdued than Gucci attorney Louis Ederer of Arnold & Porter LLP.
Petrocelli built an argument that called into question Gucci’s motive for suing Guess three years ago after what Gucci alleges was nearly two decades of infringement. The lawyer pointed to e-mails between Guess and its licensees that discussed using Gucci product as inspiration for various designs.
“When you’re sitting here in court and looking at one e-mail after another saying Gucci this and Gucci that…even to me it looks troubling…but people are confused by product, not e-mails,” Petrocelli said, addressing presiding Judge Shira Scheindlin.
“For the most part, the e-mails did not translate to the product,” he said, adding that all brands look to their competitors for inspiration. “I think if we ask for Tom Ford or Frida Giannini’s e-mails, we would see the same thing.”
Petrocelli then addressed the allegedly infringing marks, describing the script and square G designs in question as “weak trademarks” since other brands had similar designs.
Switching gears, Petrocelli said Gucci must have been aware of what it sees as Guess’ infringing designs for years. The attorney asked the court why the plaintiff waited until 2009 to sue Guess and Marc Fisher if the two firms had been knocking off Gucci for years in plain sight.
“I don’t know why they brought this case,” he said, explaining that some goods covered under the lawsuit were no longer in existence and, as a result, it was hard to reconstruct the evolution of certain marks.
“It’s their fault,” the lawyer said of Gucci. “They created the situation. They have no right to come into court.”
Marc Fisher’s lawyer, Darren Saunders of Manatt, Phelps & Phillips LLP, gave a brief synopsis of the case, parroting his co-defendant’s argument.
Saunders said Gucci’s attorney kept referring back to only a handful of the 155 allegedly infringing shoes. He said that sample wasn’t large enough to reach a broader conclusion on the case.
But Ederer wasn’t having any of it.
“This was a perfect storm of willful infringement,” he said, referring to Guess and its licensees. “It was in fact a calculated scheme. When I say calculated…I am talking about a mind-set.”
Ederer explained that the defendants’ “entire business model” was to come “as close to Gucci as you can” without being “noticed.” In the preceding weeks, Ederer presented correspondence that implied that Guess worked with licensees and manufacturers to copy Gucci patterns and designs.
“It’s all an infringement,” he said. “It’s all willful. It’s knowing and deliberate every step of the way.”
But the judge seemed somewhat influenced by the defense’s argument that if Gucci had a problem with Guess’ designs, it should have acted sooner.
She noted that Guess’ advertising showing allegedly infringing goods was widespread, and in many cases in the same magazines as Gucci’s. She asked how Gucci could miss the “infringement” for so long.
“Gucci’s focus was and is on counterfeiting,” Ederer replied, but the judge didn’t seem entirely satisfied.
After going through the allegedly infringing marks and discounting the testimonies heard over the last few weeks, the lawyer showed a slide with side-to-side comparisons of Gucci products and the defendants’ products.
“It’s time for the court to put its foot down,” Ederer said.
Although there is no deadline for the judge to reach her verdict, sources close to the case said a judgment should be delivered in the coming months.
@kith is moving into children’s. The men’s and women’s streetwear brand has launched Kidset, a Kith kids line located in New York at 64 Bleecker Street. The line includes mini versions of staple Kith pieces like the Astor bomber jacket and the Kith box logo sweatshirts, along with a wall that can display up to 120 pairs of shoes from @adidas, @newbalance, @timberland and more. #wwdfashion
“I just wanted to create this fully rounded character, but I do think what excited me most was just the opportunity to give a group of people representation that I feel needs it. I like to do characters in projects that stand for something and Karolina definitely does, so that was really exciting to me,” @ginnygardner says of her new role in @hulu’s “The Runaways.” Gardner plays Karolina Dean, a queer superhero, which is a rarity for @marvel. Read more about Gardner’s character on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: @dandoperalski)
@heriethpaul and @gracebol have a moment on the @victoriassecret fashion show 2017. See every look from the runway on WWD.com. Link in bio. (📷: @giovanni_giannoni_photo) #wwdfashion #victoriassecret #VSFashionShow
“Azzedine has been one of the biggest influences in my life. He has always been such a strong, loving, fatherly figure to me. I call him Papa. His designs are indescribably unique, they are pieces of art. He knew how to make the female form look its loveliest. I have so many memories of him; my favorite might be during my first show with him in Paris. He liked me and he wanted to help me get more work. He called all his friends at Kenzo and Comme des Garcons, and asked them to book me. They said, ‘But she can’t walk!’ And he said, ‘but she has such a great ass!' His friendship and support has been the great privilege of my career. I can't imagine life without him. Repose en paix mon Papa.” - @stephanieseymour tells @wwd. #wwdfashion (📷: @steveeichner) #alaia #azzedinealaia
Azzedine Alaïa, flanked by two of his closest friends, models Stephanie Seymour and Naomi Campbell.
He designed Seymour’s dress for her 1995 wedding to Peter Brant, and treated Campbell (who famously called him Papa), like a daughter. For more on the legendary designer, tap the link in bio. #wwdfashion #alaia #azzedinealaia