Louis Vuitton will finally have to give up its long-running lawsuit against spoof tote brand My Other Bag.In the first day of its new term, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to take up Louis Vuitton’s July appeal of last year’s Second Circuit ruling rejecting the luxury brand's claims of trademark infringement against My Other Bag, which sells canvas totes emblazoned with drawings of some of Vuitton's most popular monogram handbags.The court did not give an explanation for the denial, as is customary when deciding on the hundreds of petitions for writ of certiorari it receives before every term.A Louis Vuitton spokesman declined to comment on the decision My Other Bag attorney David Korzenik, said the decision did not come as a surprise."The outcome of this case was obvious, as all judges below have observed," Korzenik said. "Louis Vuitton has simply used it's economic power to step on the free speech rights of those who don't have their deep pockets."Louis Vuitton’s petition, which came after the house lost its trademark infringement claims at the district and appellate levels, was always a long shot. The Supreme Court only takes up an estimated 1 percent of cases each term, and one of its guiding principles in selecting a case is whether it presents an issue of “national importance.”With underlying rulings that characterized the My Other Bag totes as “an obvious attempt at humor” and competing petitions involving issues like gerrymandering, online privacy and the ever-popular First Amendment right to free speech, Louis Vuitton’s claims didn’t make the cut.[caption id="attachment_10950147" align="aligncenter" width="600"] Louis Vuitton's popular monogrammed Speedy tote (left) and My Other Bag's spoof tote.[/caption]The litigation goes back to 2015, when Louis Vuitton first took issue with a canvas tote being sold by My Other Bag with a printed image of the luxury brand's popular monogram Speedy tote, the style and monogramming of which is registered under several trademarks. Under U.S. trademark law, reproduction of registered marks is allowed in the form of a parody, generally so long as the product doesn’t create “consumer confusion” as to its origin, but there is no hard and fast legal definition of what counts as parody and what crosses the line of infringement. A big issue for courts is often to what level the parody constitutes freedom of speech.In the eyes of Louis Vuitton, My Other Bag’s totes are not being used “for expressive purposes,” but instead “to free-ride” on its famous marks. Louis Vuitton told the Supreme Court that the Second Circuit’s finding My Other’s Bag’s tote as mere parody created too broad of a standard for infringement that “seriously undermines [the Trademark Dilution Revision Act’s] overriding objective of safeguarding famous marks against dilution.”While the brand tried to argue that this called for the Supreme Court’s intervention, Jed Ferdinand, a longtime intellectual property lawyer, said at the time that the case was unlikely to get picked up. But he added that Vuitton likely had other motives for playing the odds.“If you’re Louis Vuitton you want to send a message that you’re policing the market and there’s a certain deterrent value for aggressive enforcement,” Ferdinand said. “Maybe it’ll stop somebody else.”For More, See:Chanel Wants to Put an End to ‘Shanel’ RetailerSears, Kmart Facing $1M Lawsuit Over Sanuk Yoga SandalFDA Blocks Online Beauty Co.’s Sale of Injectables, Whitening Creams
@juicebeauty, where @gwynethpaltrow holds the title of creative director of makeup, has become one of the foremost labels in the organic beauty category –– with sales on track to hit $100 million this year. What’s behind the rapid growth the brand is experiencing right now? It all started in 2005 when the wellness movement was just getting started. Read more on WWD.com. #wwdbeauty
Stay up to do date with breaking news and trending stories with WWD’s “The Essentialist.” Our newsletter delivers the top news in fashion right to your inbox. Want more info? Link in bio. #wwdfashion (📷: @kukukuba)
"I want to tell a story that inspires people to feel good about themselves, but also I'm making a commentary about the lack of female stories and female directors and saying this should change," said @imheathergraham on her latest project "Half Magic." The comedy feature, which the actress wrote and directed, is based on her own struggles as a woman in show business. Read @andrewnodell's full interview with Graham on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @jgreenery)
@meltcosmetics cofounders @lora_arellano and @danabomar built their brand on a single idea: a true matte lipstick. To set the brand apart, they said they always put their customers first –– including a personalized note in each package. #wwdsummits #wwdbeauty
@moncler unveiled its latest project, #MonclerGenius, yesterday at Milan Fashion Week. The Italian outwear maker gave show-goers a preview of the monthly collections – which were created by eight designers and creative talents including Pierpaolo Piccioli, Simone Rocha, Craig Green and more – that will start rolling out in the summer.