The New York Supreme Court judge ruled Friday that Penney’s would be allowed to sell goods designed by Stewart, which are branded with the “JCP Everyday” trademark and the “double-house” logo. Macy’s, which won a preliminary injunction over the summer to keep its rival from selling Stewart-branded wares in certain exclusive categories, promptly filed an appeal Monday.
Prior to the injunction denial, Oing had thrown out a slew of other claims alleged by Macy’s against the defendants, which included unfair competition, damages as it related to disgorgement and breach of confidentiality.
Filed in New York state appellate court Monday, the court papers document six appeals in total by Macy’s, the most crucial one being the denial of the injunction.
Both Penney’s and MSLO declined to comment on the appeal, which was expected by all parties involved in the trial.
“In denying Macy’s motion, the Supreme Court erred in several significant respects,” Macy’s said in appeal papers. “First, the court concluded that Macy’s had failed to establish that it would suffer irreparable harm absent a preliminary injunction. That was reversible error, for it is well-established in New York that the breach of an exclusive license agreement with respect to unique services or designs constitutes irreparable harm.”
In the documents, Macy’s outlined other ways in which it satisfied obtaining an injunction, as it moved for the appeal to be expedited.
Prior to making his ruling on Friday, Oing had difficulty accepting Macy’s’ argument that it would suffer irreparable harm should Penney’s be permitted to sell the unbranded wares. In most preliminary injunction hearings, lawyers can point to monetary damages suffered by the plaintiff, and therefore argue for the offending products to be pulled from store shelves. In this case, there was no such quantifiable damage, as Penney’s had yet to sell the goods, lawyers for MSLO and Penney’s argued.
Oing concluded that should Penney’s be unable to sell what amounts to warehouses filled with unbranded goods, it would cause the already ailing department store to “suffer” harm and potentially cause a “ripple effect” that could result in a lot of money lost, as well as jobs.
“The bottom line is, there is nothing in the contract that says if they are not branded with the Martha Stewart trademark, you cannot sell them,” the judge said shortly before delivering his verdict Friday. “I’m taking it all in, and I will decide it. The appellate court will tell me if I’m right or wrong.”
While the court of appeals sets a date to hear Macy’s’ arguments, the trial will continue Wednesday morning with MSLO and Penney’s putting on its respective cases.
Breaking News: @louisvuitton's men's artistic director @mrkimjones is leaving the French fashion house after nearly 7 years. Jones joined Louis Vuitton in 2011, following a three year tenure as creative director of British luxury goods brand Alfred Dunhill. Jones is to exit Louis Vuitton after showing his fall 2018 collection for the brand in Paris on Thursday. Read the full exclusive story on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
For men’s fall 2018, @giuseppezanotti drew on elements from streetwear, sport, biker, combat and rock ‘n’ roll. Pictured here are a pair of shoes from the collection, featuring zippers, rhinestones, and silver hardware. Head to WWD.com to see a roundup of the accessories from Milan’s men’s fall 2018 shows. #wwdfashion (📷: Andrea Delb)
To celebrate the 25th anniversary of @ralphlauren’s snowboarding collection, the brand is mining its archives. The iconic brand is reintroducing vintage styles and dropping new designs for a color capsule that will be available in Ralph Lauren stores and @openingceremony on January 25. The capsule will consist of 10 pieces, including the Snow Beach Pullover, pictured here, which is a collector’s item that rapper Raekwon wore in Wu-Tang Clan’s “Can It Be All So Simple” video. #wwdfashion (📷: Tom Gould)
For @rochasofficial’s pre-fall 2018 collection, creative director Alessandro Dell’Acqua channeled the sophisticated and intriguing Catherine Denevue in the film “Belle de Jour.” Polished collarless coats, midi skirts, suits and ’60s graphic motifs were all featured in the collection, adding a sense of discreet luxury. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdfashion
“We tried to produce clothing of that couture quality, but the most daunting part was that we only had a matter of days [to do it],” said costume designer Lou Eyrich, who recreated Gianni Versace’s iconic looks for @americancrimestoryfx. Eyrich searched online retailers and vintage shops for original pieces from the design house and for @penelopecruzoficial, who plays Donatella Versace. Head to WWD.com to read how she created the Versace world. #wwdfashion
Only three months after her stellar debut catwalk season, @kaiagerber has inked her first big design collaboration –– with @karllagerfeld. The collection blends Lagerfeld’s Parisian chic aesthetic and the model’s signature West Coast casual style via RTW, accessories, footwear and more. The #KarlLagerfeldxKaia collection will launch in September with a series of events. Get all the details on WWD.com. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
Harrods plans to remove the famous statue of Princess Diana and Dodi Al Fayed from the bottom of the Egyptian escalators and hand it back to Mohamed Al-Fayed. “We are very proud to have played our role in celebrating the lives of Diana, Princess of Wales and Dodi Al Fayed at Harrods and to have welcomed people from around the world to visit the memorial for the past 20 years,” said Michael Ward, Harrods managing director. “With the announcement of the new official memorial statue to Diana, Princess of Wales at Kensington Palace, we feel that the time is right to return this memorial to Mr. Al Fayed and for the public to be invited to pay their respects at the palace.” More on the news, with reporting by @loreleimarfil, at WWD.com. #wwdnews