SANTA ANA, Calif. — A mistrial was declared Wednesday in Trovata’s lawsuit alleging Forever 21 knowingly copied its designs.
Attorneys for Trovata said the Newport Beach, Calif.-based sportswear company will seek a new trial.
U.S. District Court Judge James V. Selna dismissed the jury of six men and two women after they were unable to reach a decision, apparently because of one holdout. Deliberations began on Thursday.
Juror Stephen Sharp concluded Trovata had not proved Forever 21’s combined use of largely minute design elements, such as evenly spaced four-hole buttons, a round zipper pull or alternating stripes in contrasting colors (the legal term for which is “trade dress” — the visual appearance of a product , which links it to a particular brand in consumers’ minds, constituted an infringement of Trovata’s intellectual property.
Sharp said Trovata was not a company with widely recognizable design characteristics. “It really hadn’t planted itself in the public’s mind,” he said. “It is not like a Rolex watch. Trade dress by its very nature requires a level of familiarity by the public beyond what Trovata has achieved. They are a new, young company.”
But juror Michael Marien said just because Sharp wasn’t familiar with Trovata’s unique design elements doesn’t mean they don’t exist. “I favored more of what Trovata had to say,” he said. “I know retailers team with designers. Maybe Forever 21 should have gone to Trovata and said ‘We’d like to license.’”
The Trovata lawsuit came to trial on May 12 after two years of legal maneuvering and the case was viewed as a potential linchpin in clarifying intellectual property rights in an era when knockoffs of runway looks often appear in specialty chains before designers’ original versions hit stores.
“This is a long battle for our industry,” Trovata founder John Whitledge said after the mistrial. “We are not just representing ourselves.”
Trovata alleged the $1.7 billion cheap chic retailer turned out near-identical copies of pieces worn on the runway or published in magazines — in one instance with labels inside a hoodie that were unique to Trovata. The suit covered seven Trovata pieces, including cardigans, hoodies, shirts and a jacket from fall 2005 to early 2006.
Los Angeles-based Forever 21 conceded the similarities between its garments and those of Trovata, but insisted that it broke no laws because the disputed designs were not unique to Trovata.
Trovata did not seek trademark protection for its garments, leaving trade dress as the only legal course of action, one often difficult to prove. For trade dress to be protected, it must be instantaneously identifiable in the mind of the purchaser and the features in question must not serve a functional purpose — like zippers used decoratively, rather than for garment closure.
Ann Cadier Kim, chief financial officer of Forever 21, suggested that legislators may need to clarify intellectual property issues in design. “I feel it is a shame we don’t have more defined laws than trade dress,” she said.
U.S. copyright laws do not protect the basic design, silhouette or form of a garment. Under existing law, only original artwork, such as graphics or prints on clothing, can be copyrighted.
Trovata was seeking a multimillion-dollar award for actual and punitive damages.
“We were disappointed, obviously, that they couldn’t come to a decision, but this is only the beginning,” said Frank Colucci, a lawyer for Trovata. “As long as we keep the spotlight on Forever 21, I think the designers will benefit.”
Forever 21 attorney Bruce Brunda said, “It is hard to have a positive reaction when there’s no verdict. It is just not something you can draw a lot from.”
The Trovata lawsuit, unlike the more than 50 suits brought against Forever 21 in the last three-and-a-half years by companies such as Diane von Furstenberg, Anna Sui, Anthropologie and Bebe, did not allege copyright violations. The other suits were settled out of court.
@margotrobbie steps out onto the red carpet wearing @miumiu. The actress is nominated for “Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role” in “I, Tonya” at the #SagAwards. (📷: Stewart Cook) #wwdfashion
For @massimogiorgetti of @msgm, the Nineties are his favorite decade. “They had a huge impact on my personal growth. What I like of the Nineties is that they are not so precise in terms of style as other decades…there was actually a bit of everything,” he said. As seen on MSGM’s Spring 2018 show: tie-dye and a bit of grunge, two styles that are synonymous with the decade #wwdfashion #wwddecades (📷: @kukukuba)
Breaking News: @hedislimane joins @celine as its new artistic, creative and image director. One of fashion’s preeminent image-makers and trendsetters, Slimane is to join the LVMH brand on Feb. 1 and unveil his first fashion proposition for men and women next September during Paris Fashion Week. It marks a major homecoming for Slimane, who cemented his reputation – and influenced men’s tailoring for more than a decade – as the designer of Dior Homme between 2000 and 2007. He went on to reinvent and ignite the house of Yves Saint Laurent, which he rechristened Saint Laurent, between 2012 and 2016 – all the while maintaining a close relationship with the Arnault family, which controls LVMH and Dior. Read the full exclusive story on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
“Personally I believe the Eighties have been the richest and more vivacious period for international fashion,” Giorgio Armani said when asked what his favorite decade of fashion is. It was a moment of disruption and experimentation and only thinking back to the first years of that decade is always an emotion for me, for what they have meant to me and my work.” The influence is clear in @giorgioarmani spring 2018 collection, pictured here, which was full of bright colors and unexpected prints. Read more about which decades designers loved most on WWD.com #wwdfashion #wwddecades (📷: @aitorrosasphoto)
For Lady Gaga’s only Italian show on her “Joanne World Tour,” the singer wore a range of @versace_official outfits. The standout piece: this custom-made bodysuit inspired by the brand’s spring 2018 collection. #wwdfashion (RG: @ladygaga)
@_camillaruth_ is expanding on the wellness-craze concept with @westbourne – a new NYC restaurant that’s both a healthy-minded café as well as a business that gives back to the community. Marcus works with the Robin Hood foundation to give back to The Door, a non-profit providing youth development services, and also hires employees through The Door. Read our full interview with Marcus on giving back through food on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @lexieblacklock)