The North Carolina Court of Appeals on Tuesday upheld a lower court ruling that the state could recalculate taxes owed by Wal-Mart Stores Inc. to include its subsidiaries.
The unanimous decision by a three-judge panel could have consequences for companies that use out-of-state proxies to reduce their tax obligations.
The Court of Appeals found that, in 1996, Wal-Mart transferred all of its stores’ property to a separate Delaware real estate trust. The trust, controlled by Wal-Mart Property Co., then leased the premises back to Wal-Mart Stores East Inc., a regional affiliate that operates stores in 29 states.
According to court documents, Wal-Mart Stores East deducted rent paid to the real estate trust from its net income when reporting to North Carolina. Documents showed Wal-Mart property subsidiaries paid a large portion of the rent back to Wal-Mart Stores East as dividends, which the regional division then classified as non-business income and therefore nontaxable.
In 2005, after auditing the retailer’s tax statements from 1999 through 2002, then-North Carolina Secretary of Revenue Reginald Hinton ordered Wal-Mart to file a combined return for Wal-Mart Stores East, Wal-Mart Property Co. and the trust. In May 2005, the retailer issued the state a check for $26.6 million.
The company filed suit against Hinton in 2006, alleging the state had no authority to force the combination. It sought a $30.2 million tax refund. In January 2008, a lower court issued a summary judgment in favor of the state.
The Court of Appeals ruling found that Hinton acted within the authority of state statute.
In the opinion, Judge Donna Stroud wrote, “The language of the statute is broad, allowing the secretary to require combined reporting if he finds as a fact that a report by a corporation does not disclose the true earnings of the corporation on its business carried on in this state.”
Daphne Moore, a spokeswoman for Wal-Mart, said the company is reviewing the decision and evaluating its next step. She said the company believes “all taxpayers should be able to rely on clearly defined laws that are reasonably enforced.”
My character, Dinah Madani, is just the coolest, [most] badass woman imaginable," says @amberroserevah. The actress stars in @marvel's newest series on @netflix, @thepunisher. To prepare for her role, Revah sat down with Homeland agents to get a real sense of with Dinah's day-to-day life is really like. Read our full interview on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @jilliansollazzo)
A scene from the 91st annual @macys Thanksgiving Day Parade. The parade, which boasts 50 million TV viewers and 3.5 million on-site spectators, is considered one of the largest and most watched parades in the world. (📷: Jason Szenes/EPA-REX)
The circus came to @bloomingdales 59th Street on Tuesday night and lit up Lexington Avenue with acrobatic dancers, death-defying knife throwing, sword swallowing and aerial acts with no net. The 45 minutes of theatrics built up to unveiling the holiday windows depicting @swarovski crystal-encrusted circus pieces and scenes from “The Greatest Showman” – songs from the soundtrack included. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: Joshua Scott)
The psychedelic fashion that pervaded the ’60s is back with an exhibit at the @museumofcityny. “Mode New York: Fashion Takes a Trip” chronicles the changing styles from 1960 through 1973 and features designers such as @ysl, @oscardelarenta and more. The exhibition, which is on display through April 1, is organized into four periods: First Lady Fasion, Youthquake, New Bohemia and New Nonchalance. Pictured here is model Pat Bardonella during the Garvey Day Parade in 1968. (📷: @kwamebphoto) #wwdeye #wwdfashion
“People should be a lot more honest in expressing both the dark and light of themselves. We need to give each other the space to do that because it’s the only way we can grow and evolve,” says @noelwells of her new film “Mr. Roosevelt,” which is largely based on her own struggles. Unexpectedly leaving @nbcsnl in 2014 after just one season, Wells felt set back in her self-esteem and career trajectory. She quickly refocused her energy to more personal projects, which led to the completion of “Mr. Roosevelt.” Read the rest of WWD’s interview with the “Master of None” actress on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: @jilliansollazzo)
@barbrastreisand is giving fans a chance to see her perform up close in a new concert series, which makes its debut on @Netflix today. From behind-the-scenes takes to her concert performance in Miami last December, the two-hour streaming special captures Streisand in her element. Pictured here is the singer/actress photographed for WWD in 1963. (📷: Palmieri Tony) #wwdeye #wwdarchive
@chanel and @pharrell dropped what’s being dubbed as the world’s most exclusive sneakers yesterday. The Adidas Originals NMD Hu, which Williams designed in collaboration with Chanel and @adidasoriginals, has a waiting list of over 120K people who pre-registered online at chanelatcolette.fr –– and only 500 pairs are on sale. The singer predicted the resale value of the shoes could reach $40K. Read the full interview on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdfashion (📷: Dominique Maître)
@imanshumpert is diving deeper into his creative endeavors and relaunching his clothing line, Post 90s, and is helping to raise money for the hurricane victims in St. Maarten with a jersey he’s designed with his brother. The Cleveland Cavaliers player talked to WWD about kneeling during the national anthem, working with fashion brands and how he wants to be more than an @nba player. Read the interview on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: George Chinese)