MILAN — In his closing speech at the tax trial of Domenico Dolce, Stefano Gabbana and board member and general director Cristiana Ruella, the prosecutor on Wednesday requested that the three be sentenced to two-and-a-half years in prison for tax evasion.
Prosecutor Gaetano Ruta alleged in his statement that the only purpose in selling the Dolce & Gabbana brands to the Luxembourg-based Gado Srl was to avoid paying taxes.
Ruta had the harshest words for accountant Luciano Patelli, who he viewed as the “orchestrator” of the issues at trial, asking Judge Antonella Brambilla to sentence Patelli to three years in prison. “We’ve been dealing for years with professionals in Milan and abroad that tempt entrepreneurs with promises of fiscal advantages. Cases such as this one would not exist if the Patellis of this world did not exist,” said Ruta.
He lamented a “lack of transparency that contrasts entirely” with the obligations of one of the “oldest and most noble professions” — accounting — one that he defined as “a filter between the State and each citizen.”
The prosecutor requested Alfonso Dolce, Domenico’s brother, and finance director Giuseppe Minoni be sentenced to two years in prison, while defendant Antoine Noella be absolved for lack of evidence.
The long-running case is related to the 2004 sale of the Dolce & Gabbana and D&G brands to the designers’ Luxembourg-based holding company, Gado. The Italian tax police reportedly consider Gado essentially a legal entity used to avoid higher corporate taxes in Italy.
The defendants, said Ruta, all contributed to structuring and “actively participating” in the operation. Ruta marveled at “the common front” put up by the defendants and Patelli without traces of a fallout. He noted how witnesses all pointed to the remoteness of the designers, generally described throughout the trial, which kicked off in December, as “the creative minds” distanced from decisions related to the restructuring of their company.
“Well, they are the ones who indirectly benefited the most from all of this,” Ruta remarked.
Each designer had a 50 percent stake in Dolce & Gabbana Srl, which controlled an 80 percent stake of Gado. “Thanks to the strongly beneficial tax rate, the profits were eventually channeled to them,” said Ruta.
The prosecutor described Ruella as “the loyal motor behind the restructuring of the group,” and spent most of his three-and-a-half-hour speech retracing the significant steps of the hearings to prove that Gado was an “entity devoid of content. And the brands could easily have been sold to other existing companies of the group,” he said.
“Can we actually say that Gado had activities in Luxembourg? The strategy of the defendants’ lawyers hinged on the idea that the uncomplicated structure that had been set in place to protect the brands in Luxembourg was enough,” said Ruta.
On the contrary, he said, Gado had a lack of an “autonomous organizational structure.” He questioned how employee Maria Grazia Bergomi had been transferred to Luxembourg one year after Gado was founded. “How could one employee be enough to safeguard the brands’ trademarks around the world?”
He referred to witness Vittorio Faraggiana, a Milan-based consultant on intellectual property, saying that that testimony proved that intellectual property activities related to Dolce & Gabbana were actually in the hands of outside consultants such as the Guzzi and Ravizza studio, which did “all the outsourcing. Custom authorities contacted the studio directly. And whenever substantial issues with Gado emerged, they were dealt with by individuals that did not live in Luxembourg, who did not work there and only occasionally went there,” said Ruta, pointing to board meetings that would be held “only once or twice a year. Gado was a structure functional to the realization of a fiscal advantage that was concretely obtained.”
Ruta referred to a ruling whereby Gado had a 4 percent tax rate, much lower than Italy’s of more than 30 percent.
The prosecutor also expressed doubts about the initial public offering that witnesses referred to as one of the main reasons for the designers’ decision to sell the Dolce & Gabbana brands to Gado.
“The sale was touted as a way to list in a market with an international standing, but the IPO never took place and Ruella said she was aiming for an international profile. But in 2004 you can say anything, but not that the company was not international,” said Ruta.
He added that the defendants’ lawyers have deposited reports dating back to the Nineties and until 2010 by banks and financial investors, from Morgan Stanley to Merrill Lynch and Deutsche Bank. “I would lie if I said that I read every single page, but I examined all the documents and there is not a single trace or reference to an IPO in Luxembourg. There are talks of expansion and benefits through an IPO , but there is no specific IPO project, except perhaps a mention of Hong Kong. After years of experience, I see these as approaches made by the banks and not by Dolce & Gabbana,” said Ruta.
Also, he claimed that contrary to what Ruella believed, he had seen no evidence of Dolce & Gabbana paying a 30 percent tax on royalties in Italy.
Ruta also asked Brambilla to charge witnesses Marco Tanzi Marlotti and Giovanni Ambrosetti from PricewaterhouseCoopers for perjury. “Contrary to what they said, there is no trace of an IPO in the PricewaterhouseCoopers appraisal,” said Ruta.
The defendants are being charged for omitted tax declaration as the unfaithful tax declaration accusations expired at the end of April after seven years and six months.
The plaintiff solicitor Gabriella Valadia, who spoke after Ruta, asked for a provisional fine of 10 million euros, or $13 million, citing damages to the image of the Revenue Service. “Tax evasion shows a system is not credible and efficacious, it hurts the credibility of the Italian fiscal system, aggravated by the fact that the individuals at the center of the trial are so famous,” said Valadia.
If found guilty of the charges, the defendants are expected to appeal.
There'll be no rest for those headed to Europe for men's, as Paris just closed the gap with Milan. According to a provisional calendar released by the Chambre Syndicale, Paris Men's Week will now open a day earlier on January 16. See new highlights on the official lineup on WWD.com. #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @kukukuba)
BREAKING: Jonathan Saunders is leaving @DVF. The designer has resigned from his position as chief creative officer of Diane von Furstenberg, the company said in a statement on Friday. At the time of his hire, von Furstenberg said Saunders’ arrival symbolized and facilitated her stepping back from the day-to-day duties that occupy the work of a full-time creative director. The British designer joined DVF in May 2016 and was in charge of all product categories. #wwdnews
For @versace_official’s spring ad campaign, the brand emphasized the archival prints from the spring tribute collection dedicated to the late Gianni Versace. Closing out the show were five of Gianni’s favorite models: Cindy, Naomi, Carla, Helena, and Claudia. Bowing on December 18, the new campaign is yet another tribute to supermodel-dom as the images by Steven Meisel are fronted by @iamnaomicampbell, @cturlington, @gisele and more. #wwdfashion
Four-time Oscar-nominated actress Annette Bening has been waiting 20 years to play Gloria Graham in "Film Stars Don't Die in Liverpool," which will be released on December 29. The movie about Graham – a Hollywood star known for her controversial relationship with a younger Englishman named Peter Turner – is based off a memoir Turned wrote. "She felt vulnerable to him, because she loved him, she really did love him. And anyone that we really truly are in love with, we re vulnerable to in a very deep way," said Bening. Read our full interview with the modern icon of an actress on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @ninebagatelles; Styled by @cristinaehrlich)
The crisp white button down: a staple that can be dressed up or down and accessorized throughout the decades. Here, on a Art Basel-goer in 2017 on the left and on the iconic Audrey Hepburn in “Roman Holiday” in 1953 on the right. #tbt #wwdfashion (📷: Andrew Morales)
Known for her work with @victoriassecret, 25-year-old model @georgiafowler is raising her profile in Hollywood. Fowler stars in @vincecamuto’s holiday campaign, which launched in partnership with “Pitch Perfect 3.” “Almost every shoot with Vince Camuto, I’ve had to face a fear…It was definitely a challenge. I’m so grateful for it, though. I’ve always wanted to be a pop star, so that was the perfect chance,” Fowler said. Head to WWD.com to read about Fowler’s experience modeling, including at the #VSFashionShow, and her relationship with Nick Jonas. #wwdeye (📷: @jilliansollazzo)
EXCLUSIVE: Huda Kattan just became the first beauty influencer to land a major beauty deal. Kattan's business, @hudabeauty, has received a minority investment from private equity firm TSG Consumer Partners. The brand, which industry sources say is on track to do $200 million in retail sales for 2017, will receive support on product, retail and geographic expansion through the deal. Get all the details on the deal and read @_a_collins' interview with Kattan on WWD.com. Link in bio. (📷: @jgreenery) #wwdbeauty #wwdnews
Peruvian model @juanaburga_official – who is known for walking the runways of @rodarte, @viviennewestwood and @torybuch – is making the move to the big screen with drama “Los Últimos.” The film premiered in Argentina in November and arrives in the U.S. and Europe in 2018. On making the switch from modeling to acting, Burga told WWD: “It’s a completely different thing – a lot of people think it’s similar or try to connect things, especially like getting used to the camera or being looked at all the time or playing these different characrers, but film is a completely different story.” #wwdeye (📷: @jgreenery)
London’s newly opened @designmuseum will look back on the life and work of Azzedine Alaïa in a show that the designer helped to curate before he died of heart failure last month. The retrospective, which Alaïa had worked on with Mark Wilson, chief curator of the @groningermuseum, will look at the impact of his work worldwide. The show, “Azzedine Alaïa: The Couturier,” will run from May 10 to October 7. Read more about the exhibit on WWD.com #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @zefashioninsider)