WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday rejected a petition from Tiffany & Co. asking the court to determine whether eBay Inc. can be held liable for trademark infringement.
In its petition, Tiffany claimed the online marketplace knowingly operates a site that is used to sell counterfeit products, even though eBay does not know which particular goods are fake.
The decision brings the six-year case to a close and hands eBay a major victory in the U.S. over trademark infringement cases that challenge its liability when third parties sell counterfeit products on the site.
Michelle Fang, eBay associate general counsel, said the ruling “validates eBay’s business practices,” and as in the court prior rulings, it finds that “eBay exceeds all legal requirements in the fight against counterfeits.” Tiffany executives declined to comment on the Supreme Court’s decision.
Tiffany’s petition to the high court, filed in August, appealed a decision handed down by the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan in April that certified an earlier ruling that eBay was not liable for trademark infringement or dilution for the sale of counterfeit jewelry on its site. The three-judge circuit court panel upheld a lower court’s finding that eBay had taken adequate measures to block known counterfeit dealers and that it is ultimately Tiffany’s responsibility to patrol its own trademarks.
Tiffany claimed in the petition that eBay operates a site “it knows is used to sell substantial quantities of goods that infringe” on the jewelry brand’s trademarks. The New York-based company asked the Supreme Court to consider whether eBay could be held liable under the doctrine of contributory trademark infringement.
But San Jose, Calif.-based eBay successfully argued that “limiting the scope of the doctrine keeps the primary burden for policing trademarks on the marks’ owners, who have both the economic incentive and expertise to perform this function.”
“Tiffany’s proposed interpretation [of a previous Supreme Court’s decision on the doctrine] would result in a radical shifting of the burden traditionally borne by trademark owners onto third parties,” eBay said in its response brief. “That shift would adversely impact not only eBay, but also other online services that offer important, socially beneficial secondary markets for genuine merchandise.”
London’s newly opened @designmuseum will look back on the life and work of Azzedine Alaïa in a show that the designer helped to curate before he died of heart failure last month. The retrospective, which Alaïa had worked on with Mark Wilson, chief curator of the @groningermuseum, will look at the impact of his work worldwide. The show, “Azzedine Alaïa: The Couturier,” will run from May 10 to October 7. Read more about the exhibit on WWD.com #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @zefashioninsider)
@Pharrell and his wife Helen Lasichanh were among the stars that came out to celebrate @rimowa’s first pop-up concept shop. The space, which is located on Rodeo Drive in Beverly Hills, draws inspiration from airport luggage carousels and lounge areas – and features the company’s luggage and accessories. If the pop-up is successful it could pave the way for addition temporary shops throughout the world. #wwdfashion (📷: Owen Kolasinski/BFA)
@carineroitfeld celebrated @crfashionbook’s first calendar last night with a dinner party at Spring Place in Manhattan. Photographed by @stevenkleinstudio, the calendar takes on a fitness theme and features @joansmalls, @gigihadid, @danielle_herrington_ – pictured here – and more. “[Carine Roitfeld] wanted me to feel sexy and she wanted me to be myself and feel it out on my own and do what I felt was right,” said Herrington, aka Miss October. #wwdeye
@saintrecords and @virgilabloh last night at @americanexpress’ “A Night With Success Makers” event. “I always bring it back to community because without that I wouldn’t have the courage,” said Knowles when asked how she has gotten where she is now. Read more highlights from their conversation on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @lizdoupnik)
This Just In: Industry sources have told WWD that Anastasia Soare is rumored to be considering selling her beauty business, @anastasiabeverlyhills. According to those sources, Soare has tapped investment bank Imperial Capital to explore sale options for her eponymous beauty brand –– and with at least $340 million in net sales, this would be a big deal. Put in context of other recent transactions for makeup companies, Soare’s price tag could be in the billions if she were to sell the whole thing. #wwdnews #wwdbeauty (📷: @clint_spaulding)
@assouline’s latest book, “The Spirit of Bentley: Be Extraordinary” captures the adventurous attitudes and opulent lifestyles of @bentleymotors’ most creative owners and enthusiasts throughout the U.K. The 292-page hardcover has a section dedicated to showing its team of skilled artisans and photos of its most colorful owners, from George Bamford to designer @alicetemperley, pictured here by Aline Coquelle. #wwdeye
@google released its report on the most popular search terms this year. For fashion brands, the list was led by @gucci, the luxury brand that stunned the market last October when it pledged to stop using fur. Runner ups were @supremenewyork and @fashionnova, along with more established brands like @louisvuitton, @chanelofficial and @ysl. #wwdfashion (📷: @aitorrosasphoto)
In yet another fashion show shuffle, @elleryland is moving its show in sync with the Paris couture calendar — though the brand is still keeping one foot on the city’s ready-to-wear schedule. Their runway show in January will coincide with the launch of a new strategy: designing two main collections each year instead of four, which will then be released in four drops. “As we all know, the system needs to change. We need to show sooner to give time back to artisans and designers to do what they do best — create,” said founder Kym Ellery. #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @kukukuba)
@maxmara’s classic 101801 coat was the cornerstone of its pre-fall 2018 collection. The design team expanded the traditional double-breasted, kimono-sleeved style into a trapeze coat, lean belted styles and a peacoat and presented them in monochromatic looks – like the camel one pictured here. #wwdfashion #prefall18 (📷: George Chinsee)