WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court is set to hear oral arguments Tuesday in a case involving a former Wal-Mart Stores Inc. employee whose long-term disability benefits claim was denied by the retailer’s insurance provider.
The legal question before the High Court is when the statute of limitations begins for a plaintiff to file a lawsuit against a denied long-term disability benefits claim under the Employment Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA. The Supreme Court granted writ of certiorari in April to a petition filed by Julie Heimeshoff, a former senior public relations manager for the retailer, against Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Co. and Wal-Mart.
Heimeshoff, who worked for Wal-Mart from 1985 to 2005, applied for long-term disability benefits under Wal-Mart’s ERISA plan administered by Hartford in August 2005 after she fell ill with what she said was fibromyalgia, chronic pain and other conditions. But Hartford denied her claim that December and again on a subsequent appeal in 2007, arguing its own rheumatologist consultant determined that Heimeshoff was “able to perform the activities of her sedentary occupation,” according to court documents.
Heimeshoff sued Hartford and Wal-Mart in U.S. District Court in Connecticut in November 2010, but lost after the court granted Hartford’s motion to dismiss, holding that she did not sue in a timely matter, noting that Hartford’s policy “unambiguously disallows legal action more than three years after the time written proof of loss is required to be furnished,” court documents showed.
Heimeshoff argued on appeal that the limitations period did not begin until Hartford denied her administrative appeal in 2007, after she had exhausted her administrative remedies. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals disagreed and affirmed the lower court’s decision.
The case puts Wal-Mart back in front of the Supreme Court after the retail giant won a key ruling in one of the largest gender discrimination cases in U.S. history. In 2011, the court ruled in the company’s favor in the Wal-Mart Stores Inc. vs. Dukes case, reversing an appeals court decision, and said the case could not advance as a class action because the plaintiffs did not meet the critical legal standard of commonality. Since then, groups of current and former female Wal-Mart employees have filed separate gender discrimination cases with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, as well as several new district court cases seeking class-action status.
“The reason courts have struggled with accrual of ERISA plans’ statutes of limitation is that starting a limitations period before the plan finally denies a beneficiary’s claim contradicts ERISA’s well-established requirement that the beneficiary exhaust her administrative remedies before filing suit,” Heimeshoff’s attorneys argued in its petition to the Supreme Court.
Heimeshoff’s attorneys are arguing that a “bright-line rule” is necessary for the statute of limitations on when a plaintiff can sue for a denial of a disability claim.
In opposing the writ, attorneys for Hartford and Wal-Mart contended that it is “undisputed that petitioner filed her ERISA suit long after the deadline established by the policy’s contractual limitations provision.” It wasn’t until November 2010, nearly three years after Hartford denied her appeal and five years after her proof of loss was due, that Heimeshoff sued Hartford and Wal-Mart, they argued.
The Department of Labor, which has the authority to administer ERISA, and the Solicitor General filed an amicus brief in support of Heimeshoff, arguing, “An ERISA plan cannot lawfully provide that the limitation period commences on the date the participant must provide proof of loss — i.e., early in the plan review process, well before the participant may seek judicial review. Such a provision is inconsistent with ERISA’s two-tiered remedial scheme because it sets the two procedures for redress — internal claims processes and judicial review — against each other, thereby undermining the availability and efficacy of both.”
“In Ms. Heimeshoff’s case, her policy was offered by The Hartford, which would have made any decisions about eligibility or other specific situations related to her claim,” a Wal-Mart spokesman said in an e-mailed response.
“What he has done at Vuitton is really exceptional,” said @gameofthrones’ actress Gwendoline Christie on @mrkimjones’ final show for @louisvuitton. “He has rebooted luxury in terms of making it commercial, viable and contemporary. And most importantly artistic. He has never compromised his artistic vision for the sake of commodity.” (📷: @zefashioninsider)
After seeing a demand for men’s wear from its customers, British contemporary women’s wear label @ariesarise has added a men’s wear component and will launch a unisex collection with @mrporterlive. The 20-piece collection includes jackets, denim, logo T-shirts and more with deconstructed ‘90s vibes. Set to launch on January 18, you can shop the pieces on Aries’ website and on mrporter.com. #wwdfashion
“And so spending so much time with a character who thinks like that, inevitability you try and analyze yourself and go back and think about your own demons and dark chapters that you had in your life,” says @thedanielbruhl of his role in TNT’s “The Alienist.” The show, set in the Gilded Age of New York, also stars Dakota Fanning and Luke Evans. Head to WWD.com to read about how 39-year-old Brühl prepared for the role and why he thinks the show is so relevant to today #wwdeye ( 📷: @Eriktanner)
Now that Celine Dion’s collection has topped $10 million in sales, the pop superstar, fashion icon and newly-minted industry player is eyeing growth in Asia. Read the full report by @tiffanyap, link in bio. #wwdnews #celinedion
“My personal philosophy to beauty is paying attention to oneself. I love to be outdoors, lots of fresh air, trying to take care of yourself as best you can. I always notice that comes through,” says Felicity Jones, the global face of @shiseido-owned @cledepeaubeauteus, which launches today. Head to WWD.com to read more about the actress’ love for beauty and how she prepared for her new role in “The Basis of Sex,” playing the young Ruth Bader Ginsburg. #wwdbeauty (📷: @dandoperalski)
Among the familiar faces at @off____white’s show was a surprise figure: Japanese artist @takashipom, pictured here on Wednesday morning. Other show-goers included @jerrylorenzo, who spoke about his upcoming project: a @nike collaboration for back to school, with designs inspired by his childhood on the West Coast. Sitting in the front row were Future, Don Crawley, @miguel and more. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: Stephane Feugere)
According to @laurentsai, former “Terrace House: Aloha State” cast member, she didn’t know she was auditioning for the Japanese version of “Real World.” “I was telling a couple of my friends and someone’s like, ‘That sounds a lot like Terrace House.’ I was like, ’No it can’t be.’” Turns out, it was. But Tsai isn’t just a reality star — she’s an illustrator who has worked with Starbucks Japan and most recently, she’s dipping her toes into the fashion world. Head to WWD.com to read about her time on the show, modeling and her art. #wwdeye (📷: @danieldorsa)
More changes are coming to New York Fashion Week: Beginning with the spring 2019 collection, @alexanderwangny will move his New York show to June from September, adopting a biannual schedule with collections shown in June and December. Additionally, the @cfda is planning for an official summer/winter fashion season taking place as soon as June and December 2018. Read more about the upcoming changes on WWD.com. #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @slovekinpics)