SANTA ANA, Calif. — Trovata charged in federal court that Forever 21 knowingly copied its clothing, and the cheap-chic retailer argued that the disputed designs are not unique to Trovata or protected under the law.
The outcome of the trial, which got under way late Tuesday afternoon in U.S. District Court here after two years of legal maneuvering, could clarify intellectual property rights in an era when facsimiles of runway looks are likely to appear in global specialty chains before the designers’ original versions hit stores.
“Much the same as a music composer, [the designer] takes notes, chords, sharps and flats and combines them and arranges them to make original music,” Trovata attorney Frank Colucci said in his opening statement to the jury of six men and two women. “The notes, the chords, the sharps and flats are all known; it is the way they are combined and arranged that make new music.”
Forever 21’s attorneys acknowledge that the designs are similar, but maintain the similarity does not constitute an infringement, contending that in most cases Trovata’s claims are limited to uses of buttons and other relatively common materials. The lawsuit is “an attempt to come up with a back-door patent or back-door copyright,” said lawyer Bruce Brunda, who is representing Forever 21.
“Much like a recipe for something like apple cobbler, Trovata is saying they didn’t invent the apples or the cinnamon or the sugar, but they are claiming the right to the combination,” Brunda told the jury.
Trovata, based in Newport Beach, Calif., alleges that Forever 21 turned out near-identical knockoffs of pieces worn on the runway or published in magazines — in one instance with labels inside a hoodie that were unique to Trovata.
At the heart of the case is whether Forever 21’s use of similar design elements, like buttons or color patterns, constitutes an infringement of Trovata’s intellectual property, called “trade dress,” the legal term for the visual appearance of a product that links it to a particular brand in consumers’ minds.
The suit covers seven Trovata pieces, including cardigans, hoodies, shirts and a jacket from fall 2005 to early 2006.
U.S. copyright laws do not protect the basic design, silhouette or form of a garment. Under existing law, only original artwork, such as graphics or prints, on clothing can be copyrighted.
Trovata is headed by co-founder and designer John Whitledge, who began testifying late Wednesday. The firm is seeking millions in damages for trade dress infringement.
“This is very important to the fashion industry,” Whitledge said outside the courtroom. “So many designers have struggled with this and can’t defend themselves. This is a long and expensive process.”
After the day’s proceedings, Brunda said, “There’s absolutely no consumer recognition of these [disputed] elements, no consumer testimony, so this amounts to a hypothetical case of recognition, and that doesn’t constitute trade dress.”
Los Angeles-based Forever 21 has been sued some 50 times for copyright violations in the recent years by companies such as Diane von Furstenberg, Anna Sui, Anthropologie and Bebe. This is the first time the chain has faced a jury trial. The retailer has settled cases out of court.
@chanel and @pharrell dropped what’s being dubbed as the world’s most exclusive sneakers yesterday. The Adidas Originals NMD Hu, which Williams designed in collaboration with Chanel and @adidasoriginals, has a waiting list of over 120K people who pre-registered online at chanelatcolette.fr –– and only 500 pairs are on sale. The singer predicted the resale value of the shoes could reach $40K. Read the full interview on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdfashion (📷: Dominique Maître)
@imanshumpert is diving deeper into his creative endeavors and relaunching his clothing line, Post 90s, and is helping to raise money for the hurricane victims in St. Maarten with a jersey he’s designed with his brother. The Cleveland Cavaliers player talked to WWD about kneeling during the national anthem, working with fashion brands and how he wants to be more than an @nba player. Read the interview on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: George Chinese)
Not only does #TheProfit return to CNBC tonight, but @marcuslemonis has launched @shopmarcus, a new shopping and lifestyle retail experience in Aspen and Chicago, with more locations to come. The retail stores offer in-store stylists and a variety of contemporary womenswear selections.
“It’s life, I’m going to face it,” @mingxi11 sighed. “I fell, but you know, I think the most important thing is that I get back up. I had the love, the help from my sister — the girl next to me Gizele [Oliveira] — she’s so nice. When I went backstage everybody was trying to comfort me like ‘Oh Ming, it’s OK.’ I’m really, really touched. I think it’s them who gave me the courage to go back on stage for the finale,” Xi told WWD of her fall at the @victoriassecret fashion show. (📷: David Fisher) #wwdfashion #vsfashionshow #victoriassecret
@louisvuitton tapped @therealpeterlindbergh for its latest city-centric photo book, which is part of a series called Fashion Eye. The primarily black and white book captures the spirit of Berlin in 57 images shot between 1989 and 2019. “Berlin is an inspiration for me, more than a city. I mean @millajovovich is simply Berlin!” said Lindbergh. #wwdfashion
“You know, I think audiences expect a certain performance so I have to deliver to them what they’re expecting to a certain degree. But I’m also a different actor and a different person, I have my own spin on the character,” says @noahegalvin of his takeover of the leading role in “Dear Evan Hansen” following the departure of @bensplatt, who originated the role. Read WWD’s interview with the 23-year-old actor on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: @jilliansollazzo)
For pre-fall 2018, @etro created richly-colored wonderland, using tapestries, textiles and wallpapers from the Eastern world at large. The line featured floral and graphic prints and jacquard motifs, like this two-piece look featured here. #wwdfashion (📷: Giovanna Pavesi)
@kith is moving into children’s. The men’s and women’s streetwear brand has launched Kidset, a Kith kids line located in New York at 64 Bleecker Street. The line includes mini versions of staple Kith pieces like the Astor bomber jacket and the Kith box logo sweatshirts, along with a wall that can display up to 120 pairs of shoes from @adidas, @newbalance, @timberland and more. #wwdfashion
“I just wanted to create this fully rounded character, but I do think what excited me most was just the opportunity to give a group of people representation that I feel needs it. I like to do characters in projects that stand for something and Karolina definitely does, so that was really exciting to me,” @ginnygardner says of her new role in @hulu’s “The Runaways.” Gardner plays Karolina Dean, a queer superhero, which is a rarity for @marvel. Read more about Gardner’s character on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: @dandoperalski)