NEW YORK — Score one for Ron Johnson and J.C. Penney Co. Inc.
A state judge here ruled Penney’s can move ahead, for now, with its plan to set up Martha Stewart shops next spring. That’s a setback for the Terry J. Lundgren-led Macy’s Inc., which sells Martha Stewart goods under a 2006 agreement and sued Penney’s this month to stop it from moving ahead with the home goods brand.
Penney’s lawyers agreed not to violate the terms of a prior injunction protecting Macy’s agreement to sell certain Martha Stewart-branded goods exclusively, including housewares, cookware, bedding, bath and kitchen textiles, home decor and certain furniture. Judge Jeffrey Oing said he would consolidate Macy’s cases against Penney’s and Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc. A trial is set to start in November.
Penney’s lawyer, Mark Epstein, of Munger, Tolles & Olson, painted the dispute as a broader battle between retail competitors.
“The real concern [for Macy’s] is J.C. Penney is on the rise — we’re transforming,” he said.
Under the guidance of Johnson, who is chief executive officer, Penney’s has eliminated coupons, streamlined its operations and is trading the department store format for one centered around a group of specialty shops. The financial toll of that reinvention has been worse than expected and comparable-store sales fell 20.3 percent in the first half.
Although still operating at a different price point, Penney’s approach is putting it in more direct competition with Macy’s, and Oing was careful not to get between the two.
“It’s one thing to enjoin MSLO because I believe the company is sort of the centerpiece of all these actions,” the judge said. “It’s another thing to enjoin a retailer from doing business.”
Oing said it was enough for Penney’s to agree not to sell any Martha Stewart-branded products in the categories under dispute. He did note that any harm Macy’s suffers could be satisfied with “monetary relief” and that he would have “no trouble telling J.C. Penney to yank all the items off the shelf” at some later date.
“We have two retailers here trying to get a share of market,” Oing said. “Macy’s consumers are different from JCP’s consumers. JCP is trying to increase the kinds of consumers that JCP has coming through their stores. That may or may not work. I don’t want to extend that [Martha Stewart] injunction any further and tie JCP’s hands.”
At the hearing, Penney’s argued that the contract with Macy’s doesn’t cover designs by Martha Stewart that don’t bear the brand’s name.
The judge noted, “If you’re going to sell it in a store-within-store concept…it’s almost like putting a mark on the product.”
But Penney’s lawyer, Epstein, said Macy’s was trying to get more than it got when it negotiated its deal with Martha Stewart.
“The contract does not say that any idea that [Martha Stewart] comes up with in the middle of the night in flatware, that’s Macy’s,” Epstein said. “Macy’s did not buy MSLO’s brand. They didn’t hire its designers. Macy’s bought the branding; they didn’t buy the brand.”
The judge pressed Macy’s attorney, Theodore Grossman of Jones Day: “They want to sell a spoon….If it’s not branded with the trademark, it’s not an exclusive product” under the Macy’s agreement.
“It’s not an exclusive product, but that doesn’t mean they can sell it,” Grossman replied.
Under the terms of the Macy’s contract, Martha Stewart is allowed to sell branded goods at its own stores, and lawyers for the home goods firm have argued that the Penney’s shop-in-shops qualify under that provision.
“It is the MSLO store provision that J.C. Penney is relying on to sell this item with a wink,” Grossman said for Macy’s.
Grossman also said Penney’s took steps to “double down” with Martha Stewart, agreeing on July 11 to add certain product categories. That boosted Penney’s 10-year payout to Martha Stewart by $110.5 million to $282.9 million.
Martha Stewart has also already given Penney’s designs for 900 products, which Grossman said the chain “illegally obtained.”
The judge said that it was up to Martha Stewart to adhere to his earlier injunction and that Penney’s was “on the sidelines waiting for someone to ask them to dance.”
A Penney’s spokeswoman said the firm was “pleased with the outcome” and a Macy’s spokeswoman said, “J.C. Penney has agreed that it won’t sell Martha Stewart-branded merchandise in our exclusive categories as long as the MSLO injunction is in effect….We expect to continue to exclusively sell Martha Stewart-branded merchandise in categories such as cookware, kitchen utensils, bed and bath for the term of our contract, which currently extends to January 2018.”
In yet another fashion show shuffle, @elleryland is moving its show in sync with the Paris couture calendar — though the brand is still keeping one foot on the city’s ready-to-wear schedule. Their runway show in January will coincide with the launch of a new strategy: designing two main collections each year instead of four, which will then be released in four drops. “As we all know, the system needs to change. We need to show sooner to give time back to artisans and designers to do what they do best — create,” said founder Kym Ellery. #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @kukukuba)
@maxmara’s classic 101801 coat was the cornerstone of its pre-fall 2018 collection. The design team expanded the traditional double-breasted, kimono-sleeved style into a trapeze coat, lean belted styles and a peacoat and presented them in monochromatic looks – like the camel one pictured here. #wwdfashion #prefall18 (📷: George Chinsee)
The @cfda has shifted the dates of #NYFW, with Men’s showing on February 5 through February 7, and Women’s will directly follow, running from February 8 through 14. The preliminary schedule will be released on the CFDA’s web site in the next few days, but Mark Beckham, VP of marketing for the CFDA, revealed that @rafsimons will be back to close the men’s-specific part of the week with a show on February 7 #wwdfashion (📷: Kelly Taub)
@ferragamo is introducing a new space dedicated to the development of women’s and men’s leather good samples. The laboratory, which is created eco-friendly materials and designed to reduce the environmental impact of the manufacturing processes, will allow the company to expand its accessories offering through traditional artisanal approaches. #wwdfashion (📷: @aitorrosasphoto)
How does a “regular, degular, schmegular” girl from the Bronx, N.Y., become a Grammy-nominated artist with a certified platinum record in less than a year? Call it the @iamcardib come up. The 25-year-old has become a musical sensation, and the fashion world is taking note. “If I could describe her style I would say drama. She’s really into the dramatics,” says Cardi B’s stylist @kollincarter. See how Carter styles her bold and out there looks with the link in bio. #wwdfashion
“There is no formula. There is no guideline. I can watch Ted Talks all day, but there is no one who can advise me on exactly what it is I should be doing,” said @ronniefieg, CEO of @kith, in an interview with WWD’s @ariahughes at the brand’s new SoHo office in Manhattan. Head to WWD.com to see how Fieg went from hanging out in shoe stockrooms at 13 to building his own business. #wwdfashion (📷: @weston.wells)
@fearofgod and @maxfieldla have teamed up on a pop-up installation. The store, located in the gallery space across from Maxfield’s Melrose Ave location, is the site of the brand’s House of God pop-up in which Fear of God founder @jerrylorenzo has created a church-inspired installation. A dozen vintage church pews sit in front of an LED screen playing 90s gospel singers in an effort to re-create an environment akin to a Southern Baptist Church, Lorenzo explained. Read more about the pop-up on WWD.com #wwdfashion (📷: Jennifer Johnson)
Known for his sleek, sophisticated American glamour, Norman Norell is the subject of an upcoming exhibition at @fitnyc. “Norell: Dean of American Fashion,” which runs from February 9 through April 14, will feature approximately 100 ensembles and accessories. His best work is exemplified by the designer’s glittering “mermaid” gowns frosted with thousands of hand-sewn sequins – like the one pictured. (📷: William Helburn) #wwdfashion
For pre-fall 2018, @balmain didn’t let go of the glitz. A crystal embroidered baseball jacket priced at around $40,000 hangs in the “couture” section of the brand’s first men’s pre-collection. Sporting the words “Balmain Army” across the back, the item took around two months to make. “When it was completed, it was like Christmas, it was like, ‘It’s done, it’s exactly what I wanted,’” said Balmain’s creative director @olivier_rousteing during a tour of the collection in a Paris showroom on Monday. #wwdfashion