NEW YORK — Judge Jeffrey Oing’s courtroom was considerably less hectic Wednesday following Martha Stewart’s testimony a day earlier.
With just a handful of reporters and fewer lawyers, Oing made an effort to speed up proceedings, as he addressed scheduling and housekeeping matters concerning the extension of the preliminary injunction, which he granted to Macy’s over the summer. The injunction keeps J.C. Penney Co. Inc. from selling Martha Stewart-branded goods in its stores for the time being. Earlier in the week, the judge hinted at the larger question regarding whether Penney’s should be able to sell goods designed by Stewart that have been re-branded with either the “JCP Everyday” trademark or a “double-house” logo. Those goods are part of exclusive product categories that Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc. agreed to design for Macy’s Inc. under their 2006 contract. A decision on the extension will likely indicate how the judge is leaning in the overall case.
“You will know perhaps where I’m going to go,” the judge said, referring to the extension. “I’ve been thinking about this case. I may throw something in there that will put a spin on this...and have people scratching their heads.” RELATED STORY: Martha's Moment on the Stand >>
Those ominous words hung over the courtroom as the lawyers scrambled to communicate their thoughts before they formally give their arguments Friday afternoon. MSLO’s lawyer, Eric Seiler, argued that Macy’s violated its contract with MSLO because it “failed to maximize net sales” of its Martha Stewart Collection for Macy’s. Therefore Macy’s extension of its contract with MSLO, which took place in January 2012, is invalid. It couldn’t extend a contract that was violated, he said.
Mark Epstein, Penney’s lawyer, explained that his client owns the re-branded JCP Everyday and double-house branded goods and “has the right to sell them.” For Macy’s, Robert Faxon, of Jones Day, who was standing in for Theodore Grossman, argued that the original violation took place when MSLO inked the deal with Penney’s in December 2011. Faxon didn’t want to get into his client’s position, as Grossman is the lead attorney on the case.
“You’re smart, you’re from a big firm,” Seiler said, goading Faxon on to continue unpacking Macy’s argument.
The judge tabled the discussion and turned to witnesses. With ex-MSLO chairman Charles Koppelman set to appear today, Stewart’s legal team agreed it would bring up one of its witnesses for expediency’s sake, even though Macy’s hasn’t rested its case.
Chanel Riley, a luxury bedding designer for MSLO, was called to the stand, in order to clarify the design process at her company. While she confirmed that MSLO designers do not normally work on both Macy’s and Penney’s accounts simultaneously, the Macy’s legal team brought to light that some designers had worked on one account before switching to the other.
Earlier in the day, Macy’s called Regina Corso, a survey expert from The Harris Poll. Corso administered an online survey to 401 people to determine whether Macy’s shoppers who bought Martha Stewart home goods would prefer to buy those goods at Penney’s. While her results claimed they would opt for Penney’s, the lawyers from MSLO and Penney’s poked many holes in Corso’s methodology. Oing appeared unconvinced that the survey was reliable, as it did not take into account specific home goods by category. He also noted that Stewart products have yet to be sold in Penney’s stores and asked her if the poll should be retaken should those products be available in stores.
@pantone announced their Color of the Year 2018: Ultra Violet. Nearly 20 months after the musician Prince’s death, fashion is having a purple moment. Varying shades of purple appeared on spring or fall runways, from @christopherkane to @calvinklein. @gucci’s Alessandro Michele bathed his fall runway in ultra violet-colored light at one point. Pantone 18-3838 is meant to “push the boundaries of what inspires us to look upward and outward to the future.” #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @kukukuba)
@badgalriri’s @fentybeauty launch in September was a massive success on social media, powering $72.9 million of earned media value, according to Tribe Dynamics. The brand’s foundation offering sparked conversations about diversity in beauty, launching the growth of emerging influencers and propelling the brand’s support on social media. Today, #fentybeauty won Launch of the Year at the WWD #BeautyIncAwards. (📷: Chema Moya/EPE-EFE)
@marianna_hewitt has become one of the most influential content creators in the beauty space, with almost 800,000 Instagram followers and a newly launched skin care line called @SummerFridays. Today, she was awarded Influencer of the Year at the WWD #BeautyIncAwards. (📸: @sophiachabbott )
As shopping behaviors evolve, the retail experience must follow. Head over to retail experts @colliersinternational’s Knowledge Leader series to read more about the shift in our shopping era. #colliersretail #lovecolliers
@prada opened a pop-up club, called Prada Double Club, in collaboration with German artist Cartsen Höller at @artbasel Miami. Last night, guests – including @youngparis, @ritaora and even Miuccia Prada herself – gathered in a former ice factory where the pop-up is housed for a performance from @wyclefjean. Go to WWD.com for full coverage on all the exhibits, parties and more at #ArtBaselMiami. #wwdeye (📷: @lexieblacklock)
@louboutinworld and @disney are making magic once again, creating a set of shoe designs for the release of “Star Wars: The Last Jedi.” Louboutin designed a pair of shoes for each of the film’s four female leads: Rey (@daisyridrey), Vice Admiral Amilyn Holdo (@lauradern), Captain Phasma (Gwendoline Christie) and Rose Tico (@kellymarietran). The shoes will debut on Saturday at the L.A. premiere of the latest episode. #wwdfashion
Today at the #BeautyIncAwards 2017, WWD will be joined by beauty leaders from around the world as we honor this year's most innovative people, products, brands and places. Follow along here and on Twitter for live coverage from the exclusive event. #wwdsummits (📷: @elizaflorendo)
Exclusive: Beauty superinfluencer @marianna_hewitt is launching her first-ever skin care brand with her business partner @laurengores. Their new line Summer Fridays, which will be sold exclusively at summerfridays.com starting in January, is launching with just one product – a hydrating cream Jet Lag Mask. “We wanted to focus on one product that was amazing,” said Hewitt. Read the full interview on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdbeauty #wwdnews
Michelin star-rated chef PJ Calapa marks his first solo endeavor with today’s opening of @scampinyc –– the new Southern Italian restaurant located in Manhattans’ Flatiron District. The upscale yet welcoming environment matches the menu, which includes two types of scampi: traditional Italian langoustines in butter and the Americanized version with shrimp over pasta 🍤 - pictured here. #wwdeye (📷: George Chinsee)