NEW YORK — Macy’s Inc. has fired back at Martha Stewart’s counterclaims, which alleged that the retailer breached its contract by failing to “maximize net sales” of her branded product.
In its answer to Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc., filed late Monday, Macy’s said that from 2007 to 2011, sales from third-party licenses, including Martha Stewart Collection, “actually increased.”
Furthermore, the department store said that the proportion of sales for Macy’s-owned private label has “essentially remained the same.”
This contradicts Martha Stewart’s assertion in court papers filed three weeks earlier, that Macy’s used Martha Stewart Collection products to “draw customers” into the retailer, where its own private label brands “take center stage.”
Martha Stewart claimed that its collection helped the retailer’s private label brands “generate higher profits for Macy’s without the burden of paying royalties to a licensor like MSLO.” Martha Stewart also claimed that Macy’s turned down additional product designs, leaving “untold profits on the table.”
Macy’s countered that assertion, stating that Martha Stewart “acquiesced” to all of its decisions, and that the process was a “collaborative” one.
The back and forth between both parties comes after Macy’s sued Martha Stewart in New York State court in January for breach of contract. Central to the lawsuit is whether Martha Stewart violated her 2006 agreement to make and sell certain branded products exclusively to Macy’s by inking a deal to sell branded products to J.C. Penney Co. Inc.
Lawyers for Martha Stewart have contested that their client has the right to sell its products in MSLO-branded shops-in-shop, citing that the lawsuit never mentions the contract’s definition of an MSLO store, which it says is “any retail store branded or operated by MSLO or an affiliate of MSLO or that otherwise prominently features Martha Stewart marks or Stewart property.”
In December, Martha Stewart sold a 16.6 percent stake in its business to Penney’s and signed a 10-year agreement that will create outposts devoted to the brand in Penney’s, beginning in February 2013. That’s right after the five-year deal with Macy’s expires. Macy’s, though, maintains that it has the “unilateral right” to extend its five-year agreement with Martha Stewart. It exercised that right on Jan. 23, the same day it sued Martha Stewart. Macy’s now claims its agreement with Martha Stewart does not expire until January 2018.
But Martha Stewart’s lawyers have argued that the retailer’s recent “attempt” to renew its agreement is “null and void and of no force and effect.” As a result, they say the Macy’s agreement will therefore expire in 2013 and cannot be renewed.
@margotrobbie steps out onto the red carpet wearing @miumiu. The actress is nominated for “Outstanding Performance by a Female Actor in a Leading Role” in “I, Tonya” at the #SagAwards. (📷: Stewart Cook) #wwdfashion
For @massimogiorgetti of @msgm, the Nineties are his favorite decade. “They had a huge impact on my personal growth. What I like of the Nineties is that they are not so precise in terms of style as other decades…there was actually a bit of everything,” he said. As seen on MSGM’s Spring 2018 show: tie-dye and a bit of grunge, two styles that are synonymous with the decade #wwdfashion #wwddecades (📷: @kukukuba)
Breaking News: @hedislimane joins @celine as its new artistic, creative and image director. One of fashion’s preeminent image-makers and trendsetters, Slimane is to join the LVMH brand on Feb. 1 and unveil his first fashion proposition for men and women next September during Paris Fashion Week. It marks a major homecoming for Slimane, who cemented his reputation – and influenced men’s tailoring for more than a decade – as the designer of Dior Homme between 2000 and 2007. He went on to reinvent and ignite the house of Yves Saint Laurent, which he rechristened Saint Laurent, between 2012 and 2016 – all the while maintaining a close relationship with the Arnault family, which controls LVMH and Dior. Read the full exclusive story on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdnews #wwdfashion
“Personally I believe the Eighties have been the richest and more vivacious period for international fashion,” Giorgio Armani said when asked what his favorite decade of fashion is. It was a moment of disruption and experimentation and only thinking back to the first years of that decade is always an emotion for me, for what they have meant to me and my work.” The influence is clear in @giorgioarmani spring 2018 collection, pictured here, which was full of bright colors and unexpected prints. Read more about which decades designers loved most on WWD.com #wwdfashion #wwddecades (📷: @aitorrosasphoto)
For Lady Gaga’s only Italian show on her “Joanne World Tour,” the singer wore a range of @versace_official outfits. The standout piece: this custom-made bodysuit inspired by the brand’s spring 2018 collection. #wwdfashion (RG: @ladygaga)
@_camillaruth_ is expanding on the wellness-craze concept with @westbourne – a new NYC restaurant that’s both a healthy-minded café as well as a business that gives back to the community. Marcus works with the Robin Hood foundation to give back to The Door, a non-profit providing youth development services, and also hires employees through The Door. Read our full interview with Marcus on giving back through food on WWD.com. #wwdeye (📷: @lexieblacklock)