The New York state court judge delivered a slew of rulings regarding the contract dispute brought forth by Macy’s Inc. against Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc. and J.C. Penney Co. Inc.
Early in the day, Oing denied Martha Stewart’s argument to dismiss its exclusivity of design claim.
Essentially, the judge’s decision deemed that there is sufficient evidence to show that MSLO breached its contract when it designed product for Penney’s. A day earlier, the court found that MSLO did not violate its contract in terms of confidentiality. On Thursday, Oing also:
• Agreed that Penney’s didn’t violate confidentiality either.
• Dropped Macy’s claims that Penney’s intentionally interfered with the MSLO/Macy’s contract.
• Dismissed Macy’s claim for damages as it relates to disgorgement. This means that Macy’s will not get MSLO’s design fee that it obtained from designing product in exclusive categories for Penney’s. MSLO said the fee amounted to about $4 million.
But it was the Macy’s design exclusivity claim that was the most significant ruling of the day, even though the judge said afterward that the ruling “does not mean Macy’s will prevail” in the larger case.
The ruling indicates that Macy’s has convinced him enough to believe MSLO did commit some sort of breach when it designed product for Penney's.
The ruling also plays a role in whether Penney’s will be able to sell warehouses filled with product designed by Martha Stewart bearing the “JCP Everyday” trademark and the “double-house” logo. This question will be tackled today when the judge will hear arguments concerning whether the preliminary injunction, which he issued over the summer, will be expanded to include these nonbranded wares.
Currently, MSLO has been banned, on a preliminary basis, from selling its branded wares in Penney’s stores, and because of that, Penney’s has thus far halted the process of creating Martha Stewart shops-in-shop that will stock her branded goods. In 2011 the department store signed a deal with MSLO to sell these branded and unbranded wares in its stores. Penney’s also bought a 16.6 percent stake in MSLO.
Thursday’s ruling on design exclusivity followed a back and forth between MSLO lawyer Eric Seiler and Macy’s Inc. lawyer Theodore Grossman over MSLO’s ability to design for multiple partners.
Seiler argued that MSLO should be able to design for whomever, even though Macy’s has a contract to sell Stewart-branded and designed product in exclusive categories for the retailer. Instrumental to Seiler’s argument was that the Macy’s/MSLO contract, which was inked in 2007, doesn’t say Macy’s “owns” MSLO’s designs. In fact, he argued, it doesn’t “directly” address design when it comes to exclusivity.
“MSLO has licensed to Macy’s the exclusive use of the Martha Stewart trademark,” Seiler said. “Once its [product] is tied to the trademark or Stewart property, they have exclusivity.”
The lawyer added that Macy’s doesn’t have the “right” to get all of his client’s design ideas.
Oing said that would assume that “design is one area and the trademarking is another, that they are mutually exclusive.”
The word “exclusive” was emphasized by Grossman, of Macy’s, who said that “exclusive means unique.”
“There is no language in this contract that carves out an exception to that term,” he said. “Macy’s intended to get all designs in these categories.”
Grossman called the Macy’s/MSLO deal “extraordinary” because both parties had the same intention, namely that MSLO would design product exclusively for Macy’s and that the retailer would have the “right of first refusal” when it came to deciding whether to make those wares.
Before he hears arguments on the potential expansion of the preliminary injunction today, Oing will decide whether to throw out Macy’s claims that Penney’s competed unfairly when it entered into the MSLO partnership.
It appeared as though Oing was unfazed by the unfair competition claims, as he noted the “highly competitive” nature of the retail industry, and that Macy’s has not unearthed evidence that trade secrets had been revealed by MSLO to Penney’s.
“The retailers are out there putting on their Inspector Clouseau hats,” he said, referring to the fact that industry hands and executives are constantly doing research on their rivals. “Mr. [Terry] Lundgren, Ms. [Martha] Stewart and Mr. [Ron] Johnson are all very competitive by nature. That’s why they are good at what they do.
Jokes aside, Oing warned the lawyers that he would prefer not weighing in on today’s all-important preliminary injunction expansion.
“This is a business deal that you should not have the courts involved in,” he said. “Once I start doing certain things, you cannot turn back. I cannot express that enough. There’s a lot at stake.”
Although the case is still up in the air, one thing is fairly certain; however Oing rules on the injunction, an appeal on his decision is largely expected.
As one of the most recognizable models in the world, Christy Turlington Burns has an insider’s view of the fashion industry and the allegations of sexual harassment swirling around it. “I can say that harassment and mistreatment have always been widely known and tolerated in the industry. The industry is surrounded by predators who thrive on the constant rejection and loneliness so many of us have experiences at some point in our careers,” Turlington told WWD, along with her suggestions for how the modeling world should protect younger women and men. Read more on WWD.com. Link in bio. (📷: Tony Palmieri) #wwdnews
@asics America has tapped a new brand ambassador: famed DJ/record producer @steveaoki. This initiative is intended to set the tone for the new brand identity and philosophy and will include partnerships with influencers and in-store and off-line activations that will continue into next year. This is Asics’ most significant marketing effort in two decades, and is expected to attract younger consumers to the brand. #wwdfashion
24-year-old Jean Prounis is redefining the rules of jewelry. Formerly a studio assistant to Jemima Kirke and a design apprentice at Ghuran, she focuses on handcrafted subtleties and ancient goldsmithing techniques. “There was a really sterile feel in the environment and I wanted to have jewelry with character that shapes how you wear it everyday,” Prounis said. Each piece is hand made in New York, either by Prounis or three other jewelers in the district. #wwdfashion
“These collections continue to build on that vision, empowering differently abled adults to express themselves through fashion,” said @tommyhilfiger of his line of adaptive apparel, which launches today. The line consists of 37 men’s and 34 women’s styles based upon the pieces from the spring Tommy Hilfiger sportswear collection. #wwdnews
“Stranger Things” is getting a new cast member for season 2. Meet @sadiesink_, the 15-year-old who will be joining the Netflix series for its new season. You may recognize her from “The Glass Castle” with Brie Larson and Woody Harrelson, but the Texas native’s next role goes in an entirely different direction. She describes her character, Max, as “a rough and tumble skater girl [who] becomes friends with the boys at school.” The second season debuts on October 27. (📷: @jgreenery) #wwdeye
Amid the Harvey Weinstein controversy, there’s another sector that’s being put under the spotlight for sexual abuse: the modeling industry. While rumors about abuse and sexual harassment of female and male models — and the photographers, agents and others who perpetrated it — have circulated within the fashion world for years, model @cameronrussell started posting stories from models on Instagram last week about abusive situations they’ve encountered — from sexual harassment and molestation to attempted rape. Over 75 have weighed in so far. Read more on WWD.com. Link in bio. #wwdnews
To celebrate its 16th anniversary, @dylanscandybar tapped designers and celebrities to create mosaics out of candy. The mosaics will be auctioned off to support the philanthropic cause of each participant’s choice. Pictured here is the mural created by @aliceandolivia's Stacey Bendet. For a first look at some of the other artwork being unveiled tonight, go to WWD.com. #wwdeye
The annual Veuve Clicquot Polo Classic in Pacific Palisades this weekend drew Kate Hudson, Tracee Ellis Ross, Laura Dern and more. See pictures of the star-studded event on WWD.com. (📷: @chelsealaurenla) #wwdeye
In his new book “Hollywood Royale,” Andy Warhol’s Protégé Matthew Rolston celebrates the Eighties revival of Hollywood glamour. Featuring more than 100 portraits taken by Rolston from 1977 to 1993, the book contains photos of icons like Michael Jackson, Cyndi Lauper, and @drewbarrymore, pictured here in 1991. “Hollywood Royale,” out today, will be accompanied by an exhibition opening at Los Angeles’ Fahey/Klein Gallery on March 1. #wwdeye