NEW YORK — J.C. Penney Co. Inc. and Martha Stewart may want to wait to uncork the Champagne.
An appeals court judge said late Tuesday that Penney’s would be unable to sell Martha Stewart-designed goods bearing the “JCP Everyday” and “double-house” logos in its stores until Thursday, when he renders a final ruling on whether to grant Macy’s Inc. a temporary restraining order.
Penney’s can sell the goods on its Web site, however, and it currently has the wares up for sale there until instructed otherwise.
The decision, which was rendered by New York Associate Appellate Court Judge Richard Andrias, comes after New York Supreme Court Judge Jeffrey Oing ruled that Penney’s could sell the goods. Oing’s ruling on Friday denied Macy’s’ request to broaden the preliminary injunction that he issued over the summer to include wares designed by Stewart. Under the existing injunction, Penney’s can’t sell certain goods that fall under Macy’s exclusive categories that are branded with the Martha Stewart trademark.
Should Andrias grant Macy’s the temporary restraining order, Penney’s will be barred from selling the unbranded goods until a panel of appeals court judges mulls over whether to reverse Oing’s decision and decide on a host of other rulings he made last week. This will likely take place within a week to 10 days, according to Macy’s.
Calling Andrias “very competent,” Oing professed his respect for his colleague, but noted in court Wednesday: “I think he may reverse me, but that’s OK.”
Whether or not that transpires, the trial will continue Thursday morning with Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc. trying its side of the case.
The breach of contract trial, which began in late February, pits Macy’s against MSLO and Penney’s. In late 2011, MSLO inked a deal with Penney’s to design goods for its stores bearing the Martha Stewart trademark. As part of the transaction, Penney’s also paid $38.5 million for a 16.6 percent stake in MSLO and two board seats. By doing this, Macy’s claims, MSLO violated its contract, which it signed in 2007 and renewed last year, to design wares for the retailer in exclusive product categories.
Although Macy’s rested its case last week, its lead attorney, Theodore Grossman, tried Wednesday to reopen discovery on products MSLO designed for Penney’s. That request was quickly shot down, as Oing, whose patience has been wearing thin, told the lawyer that his side of the case was “done.”
“I’m ready to take on the defendants’ case,” Oing said. “This case has got to be wrapped up by next Friday, April 26.”
MSLO attorney Eric Seiler chimed in, adding: “You don’t get a do-over in the middle [of the trial].”
Seiler said starting Thursday morning, he intends to prove that there was no “design exclusivity” written into the Macy’s-MSLO contract, and that his client was free to design for any partner, in any product categories. He wouldn’t “push” the issue of contract violation, however.
Penney’s lawyer Mark Epstein did not outline his case but noted that he would be able to wrap up his side by April 26 as well. Oral arguments are likely to take place soon after, as both Oing and Seiler have other trials coming up.
Before adjourning for the afternoon, Oing addressed the issue of the Martha Stewart-branded stemware currently being sold by Penney’s. Macy’s contends that this is a violation of the preliminary injunction, but Penney’s and MSLO said the merchandise, including plastic glasses and pitchers, falls under the “celebrations” category, which isn’t covered under the Macy’s contract.
“It’s not as pressing,” Oing told Grossman, adding that he should enter a motion to “enforce” the injunction and that he will decide the issue from there.
Grossman seemed a bit exasperated, even though he had been beaming earlier from Andrias’ decision.
“This isn’t a game of roulette,” the lawyer said. “This isn’t a game of chance.”
“What he has done at Vuitton is really exceptional,” said @gameofthrones’ actress Gwendoline Christie on @mrkimjones’ final show for @louisvuitton. “He has rebooted luxury in terms of making it commercial, viable and contemporary. And most importantly artistic. He has never compromised his artistic vision for the sake of commodity.” (📷: @zefashioninsider)
After seeing a demand for men’s wear from its customers, British contemporary women’s wear label @ariesarise has added a men’s wear component and will launch a unisex collection with @mrporterlive. The 20-piece collection includes jackets, denim, logo T-shirts and more with deconstructed ‘90s vibes. Set to launch on January 18, you can shop the pieces on Aries’ website and on mrporter.com. #wwdfashion
“And so spending so much time with a character who thinks like that, inevitability you try and analyze yourself and go back and think about your own demons and dark chapters that you had in your life,” says @thedanielbruhl of his role in TNT’s “The Alienist.” The show, set in the Gilded Age of New York, also stars Dakota Fanning and Luke Evans. Head to WWD.com to read about how 39-year-old Brühl prepared for the role and why he thinks the show is so relevant to today #wwdeye ( 📷: @Eriktanner)
Now that Celine Dion’s collection has topped $10 million in sales, the pop superstar, fashion icon and newly-minted industry player is eyeing growth in Asia. Read the full report by @tiffanyap, link in bio. #wwdnews #celinedion
“My personal philosophy to beauty is paying attention to oneself. I love to be outdoors, lots of fresh air, trying to take care of yourself as best you can. I always notice that comes through,” says Felicity Jones, the global face of @shiseido-owned @cledepeaubeauteus, which launches today. Head to WWD.com to read more about the actress’ love for beauty and how she prepared for her new role in “The Basis of Sex,” playing the young Ruth Bader Ginsburg. #wwdbeauty (📷: @dandoperalski)
Among the familiar faces at @off____white’s show was a surprise figure: Japanese artist @takashipom, pictured here on Wednesday morning. Other show-goers included @jerrylorenzo, who spoke about his upcoming project: a @nike collaboration for back to school, with designs inspired by his childhood on the West Coast. Sitting in the front row were Future, Don Crawley, @miguel and more. See the rest of the photos on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: Stephane Feugere)
According to @laurentsai, former “Terrace House: Aloha State” cast member, she didn’t know she was auditioning for the Japanese version of “Real World.” “I was telling a couple of my friends and someone’s like, ‘That sounds a lot like Terrace House.’ I was like, ’No it can’t be.’” Turns out, it was. But Tsai isn’t just a reality star — she’s an illustrator who has worked with Starbucks Japan and most recently, she’s dipping her toes into the fashion world. Head to WWD.com to read about her time on the show, modeling and her art. #wwdeye (📷: @danieldorsa)
More changes are coming to New York Fashion Week: Beginning with the spring 2019 collection, @alexanderwangny will move his New York show to June from September, adopting a biannual schedule with collections shown in June and December. Additionally, the @cfda is planning for an official summer/winter fashion season taking place as soon as June and December 2018. Read more about the upcoming changes on WWD.com. #wwdnews #wwdfashion (📷: @slovekinpics)