As fashion executives continue to ponder how to address the issue of underweight models, there is one more piece to add to the debate: legal ramifications.
Without an overarching national requirements in the U.S. regulating a model's weight, such as those implemented in Italy and Spain last year, it's up to individual organizations and executives to set company policy on the issue. Companies looking to implement policies on models' weight need to keep in mind legal requirements, particularly in the area of discrimination, according to legal observers.
"The general concern we wanted to raise to employers in the fashion industry is, while they should address this issue, they need to be careful how they do it," said Patricia Slovak, partner with Schiff Hardin and current chair of the American Bar Association Section of Labor and Employment Law.
Specifically, Slovak said, fashion companies need to be aware of potential discrimination lawsuits and accusations around the issue of weight from an employment perspective. From health and psychological points of view, the "unhealthy weight" of models is a concern, she said. What many employers in the fashion industry might overlook is some legal precedents relating weight to disabilities.
There are several cases on record in which the courts have said that anorexia, for example, is considered a disability and as such is protected under the Americans With Disabilities Act. While the cases on record don't currently address models or employment in the fashion industry, there's no reason the precedent couldn't apply, Slovak warned.
To avoid potential lawsuits over such issues, employers need to be careful how they proceed in regard to modeling requirements, just as they would be mindful of other potential discrimination issues.
The overlying standards of the Americans With Disabilities Act dictate that employers establish the legitimate requirements of a job and ensure that they are not refusing to hire employees who could complete that job simply because of a disability. Under the protections of the act, a candidate cannot be passed over for a job only because he or she has a disability, if an employer could accommodate the person with a reasonable amount of adjustments.
So if a model has been diagnosed with anorexia and reveals that in an interview the employer could be considered to have received notice of a potential disability, Slovak said. A hiring decision could not be made based on that diagnosis, regardless of what policies on healthy weight a company might have in place.
Hermès is launching a Laundromat pop-up shop in NYC - dubbed Hermèsmatic - where customers can bring their old scarves to be dip-dyed by an expert. Get all the details on WWD.com. #wwdnews (📷: @donstahl)