PARIS -- Yves Saint Laurent took Ralph Lauren to court here Wednesday, and things got pretty testy.
Lawyers for Yves Saint Laurent Couture argued before a commercial court that Lauren had copied a tuxedo dress by the French designer, and demanded damages of $868,000 (5 million francs).
But in a surprise move, Ralph Lauren's attorney, Dominique Mennard, counterattacked and demanded damages of $174,000 (1 million francs) for defamation of character for "insults contained in an article in Women's Wear Daily," made by YSL Couture president Pierre Berge.
"Pierre Berge has talent. He knows a lot about ballet and opera. Maybe he should stick to talking about that," said Mennard, referring to remarks by Berge in WWD, April 11.
In that article, Berge said, "It's quite one thing to 'draw inspiration' from another designer; it's quite another to rip off a design, line for line, cut for cut, which is what Ralph Lauren did. That's entirely unacceptable and has to be stopped."
At one stage, the proceedings turned into a fashion show, as models wearing the YSL and Lauren dresses at the heart of the dispute strode into the court.
"I know something about fashion," said Judge Madelaine Cotelle, dressed in judicial robes and wearing Salvatore Ferragamo pumps, as she inspected the dresses. "Clearly, there are differences in the two dresses. Saint Laurent's dress is made of a different fabric and has pockets, unlike Lauren's. And his buttons are gold, while Mr. Lauren's are not. The Saint Laurent dress also has wider lapels, and I must say is more beautiful -- though, of course, that will not influence my decision."
Later, YSL's ready-to-wear version was shown, as well.
Francine Summa, YSL's lawyer, told the court Saint Laurent designed the tuxedo dress for a couture collection in 1970.
He subsequently reinterpreted the design in his fall-winter 1992-'93 couture collection, and created a similar, though shorter, dress for the YSL Rive Gauche rtw collection of spring-summer '93, Summa said.
YSL became aware of the Lauren tuxedo dress when it appeared in a fashion editorial in the December 1992 French magazine Jours de France Madame, Summa said. She said YSL's investigators learned that Lauren sold 123 "copies" for about $1,000 (5,800 francs) each.Summa told the court she met Lauren representatives on three occasions in 1993 to discuss YSL's charges, but they failed to reach a resolution.
"The tuxedo dress belongs to the artistic patrimony of the house of Saint Laurent. It's a unique original and thus cannot legally be copied by anyone else," said Summa. Any difference between the Saint Laurent and Lauren dresses was just an attempt to hide the plagiarism, she insisted. She added that YSL is also demanding that Lauren print an apology in prominent fashion publications.
In his reply, Lauren attorney Mennard argued that Giorgio Armani, Valentino, Karl Lagerfeld and others all had designed and sold tuxedo dresses. However, when the judge challenged Mennard to present photographic proof, the lawyer said he had not had time to do so.
"That's funny. There's a fashion museum five minutes from here with tens of thousands of clothes and images. It should not have been so difficult," Cotelle scolded Mennard.
And, in a remark which brought smiles to the Saint Laurent entourage, Cotelle said, "Many industrial ready-to-wear producers have made the tuxedo dress, but Mr. Saint Laurent was the first to cut off the sleeves. There's no trace of that concept before him."
Mennard noted that as soon as the dispute arose, Polo Ralph Lauren Corp. took the dress off the market. Mennard also complained that, at the request of Saint Laurent, police had searched Lauren's headquarters here.
Mennard also attacked Berge for what he described as "insults and calumnies" against Lauren in WWD, as the judge passed around translations of the story.
"This case involves two designers of great talent, reputation and success," Mennard said. "This case is not a question of money. When I read Mr. Berge's remarks, I felt great anger and consternation. Ralph Lauren isn't hiding away in Taiwan. He's an internationally famous designer with a large staff that's very proud to work for him. But he has been pilloried. "The damage has been done. Mr. Berge has once again spoken before the law has spoken. He's been very imprudent. WWD is the leading source of information in the world for fashion," Mennard continued.But the judge cut him off: "You don't have to tell me what WWD is. It's the bible of fashion and luxury. I know it well, and I was very surprised to read Mr. Berge's phrases. They were most regrettable. Calling someone a thief, which is effectively what he did, is very insulting."
To which, Summa responded: "It may have been wrong for Pierre Berge to speak this way, but what Ralph Lauren did was much worse."
The judge said she will render her decision on May 18.
Lauren's representatives in the U.S. declined comment and YSL officials could not be reached for further comment on the suit.
The annual Veuve Clicquot Polo Classic in Pacific Palisades this weekend drew Kate Hudson, Tracee Ellis Ross, Laura Dern and more. See pictures of the star-studded event on WWD.com. (📷: @chelsealaurenla) #wwdeye
In his new book “Hollywood Royale,” Andy Warhol’s Protégé Matthew Rolston celebrates the Eighties revival of Hollywood glamour. Featuring more than 100 portraits taken by Rolston from 1977 to 1993, the book contains photos of icons like Michael Jackson, Cyndi Lauper, and @drewbarrymore, pictured here in 1991. “Hollywood Royale,” out today, will be accompanied by an exhibition opening at Los Angeles’ Fahey/Klein Gallery on March 1. #wwdeye
"Nowadays when life is not so happy with everything going on in the world, I think people come to me for a little bit of whimsy and color and fun." - Designer Rebecca De Ravenel on her cult-favorite jewelry line. (📸 : @vsteves) #wwd40
“Everyone is talking about how the retail industry is struggling, but I think it’s an incredible time because brands who are doing something different and innovative are setting themselves up for the future,” said @adamgoldston, who founded the luxury athletic brand @apl with his brother @ryangoldsten. The Goldston’s are part of WWD’s 40 under 40: a group of industry notables. See the rest of the list on WWD.com. (📷: @vsteves) #wwd40
@eyeswoon blogger Athena Calderone debuted her first-ever cookbook, “Cook Beautiful,” which is heavily centered on the presentation and visual expression of food. Pictured here are her miso glazed carrots from the book. Get the recipe on WWD.com. (📷: @johnny_miller_) #wwdeye
“It’s passion that helps get anybody to a certain point and it’s what’s propelled me,” said Kith founder @ronniefieg, one of WWD’s 40 under 40: a group of industry notables who are changing the face of retail, fashion and beauty. Fieg, who opened a Manhattan flagship on October 7, began his career at age 13 as a stock boy and salesman for footwear chain David Z. “I think staying true to [my] beliefs, hard work and passion have gotten me to where [Kith] is today.” See the rest of the 40 at WWD.com. (📷: @vsteves) #wwd40
25-year-old @samweaving is about to break out this fall, starring in Netflix’s horror film “The Babysitter,” fittingly out today on Friday the 13th. That’s not the only place you’ll be seeing her, though — Weaving’s got a role Showtime’s “SMILF” and another alongside Frances McDormand and Woody Harrelson in “Three Billboards Outside Ebbing, Missouri.” Though she’s got a full plate at the moment, there’s one role she’s got her eye on: Marilyn Monroe. “I’m a little too young at the moment, but it’s on my bucket list,” the actress told WWD (📷: @dandoperalski) #wwdeye
BFF's Poppy Jamie and Suki Waterhouse celebrated the launch of their bag line Pop x Suki at Nordstrom last night. "The line is really about our friendship, and how we are so different but complement each other," said Waterhouse. 👯 (📷: Katie Jones) #wwdeye
After designing the new @louisvuitton and @bulgariofficial flagships and a @chanelofficial boutique opening in Japan, @petermarinoarchitect has another project on his plate: The Lobster Club. Located in the Seagram Building, it’s the famed architect’s first restaurant project in New York, serving up modern Japanese brasserie-style cuisine. Bronze hues, bespoke material detailing, blush and chartreuse tones and a heavy emphasis on Picasso can be seen throughout. Mark your calendars for Nov. 1 for the much-anticipated opening. (📷: @clint_spaulding) #wwdeye