WASHINGTON — The World Trade Organization handed the EU another victory Friday in a ruling that authorizes the trade bloc to impose $4.04 billion in sanctions on a wide range of U.S. products.
The ruling, which could provoke a trade war, stems from a long-simmering dispute the U.S. lost eight months ago over tax breaks for U.S. corporations operating abroad. The WTO deemed those breaks an illegal subsidy in January.
"We are satisfied by today’s decision that makes the cost of noncompliance with the WTO crystal clear," EU Trade Commissioner Pascal Lamy said in a statement Friday. "The arbitrators have endorsed the EU’s request, i.e., they have given us an amount of potential countermeasures, which will create a major incentive for the U.S. to eliminate this huge illegal subsidy."
In the latest round of the dispute, the EU had argued the $4.04 billion of U.S. products it wants to retaliate against equals the foreign income tax-break edge provided to U.S. companies. The U.S. claimed the value of tax breaks was $1 billion.
"I’m disappointed that the arbitrator did not accept the lower figure put forward by the U.S.," said U.S. Trade Representative Robert Zoellick. "I believe that today’s findings will ultimately be rendered moot by U.S. compliance with the WTO’s recommendations and rulings in this dispute."
The EU has said it will levy duties of up to 100 percent on a wide range of U.S. products, including knit and woven apparel, accessories, footwear, cosmetics and fine jewelry in a proposed list.
Lamy assured the U.S. that before any countermeasures are taken, the 15 EU member states will "carefully evaluate progress made on U.S. implementation" of a legislative fix.
He warned, however, that the U.S. must repeal the tax scheme "expeditiously."
EU officials must now submit a final list of products to the WTO dispute panel. Countermeasures can be taken any time after the final WTO authorization has been granted.
Wal-Mart Stores Inc., of Bentonville, Ark., is very concerned about the legislative fix currently under way in Congress.
In late July, David Bullington, Wal-Mart’s vice president for taxes joined executives from other major U.S. companies in warning a Senate panel that U.S. companies with foreign operations could lose millions and be less competitive globally if Congress isn’t careful in fixing the tax-break issue.Bullington told the Senate Finance Committee a simple solution would be to reduce the corporate tax rate across the board, which would benefit all businesses.
But cutting corporate taxes, always a contentious issue in Washington, has been set aside as a GOP priority since federal coffers are being hit by the slow economy and the cost of the war on terrorism.
The House Ways and Means Committee, where any tax change must originate, has been working on changing the tax code but progress has been slow.
Committee Chairman Bill Thomas (R., Calif.) has introduced a bill that calls for outright repeal of the offending tax break, but his proposal is meeting with opposition among GOP colleagues in the Republican-controlled House.
An estimated 4,000 U.S. corporations now benefit from the foreign income tax break, but most apparel manufacturers and retailers do not benefit from the program.
It is unclear what kind of impact EU retaliation on apparel and other related items would have on the majority of U.S. retailers and apparel vendors. Most U.S.-brand apparel sold in Europe is manufactured in Asia or other third-party nations and shipped directly to Europe, and those shipments would not be affected.
"Most of our goods go directly from vendors in Asia to the EU," said Frank Kelley, vice president of international trade and government affairs at Liz Claiborne. "We do very little production in the U.S. that is sent to Europe."
However, U.S. companies who do ship U.S.-made goods to the EU could be affected.
"Europe is one of our larger export markets for finished products," said Stephen Lamar, vice president at the American Apparel & Footwear Association.
Exclusive: @britneyspears is continuing to expand her brand. The pop icon, who appears in @kenzo ’s latest campaign, is partnering with Epic Rights to launch a line of branded merchandise. Read @hernameislex ‘s story, link in bio. #wwdnews #britneyspears
The Duchess of Cambridge channeled Princess Diana’s look upon giving birth to Prince Harry, when she and the Duke of Cambridge departed the hospital with the new baby Prince this afternoon in London. #wwdeye #princeofcambridge
The new Prince of Cambridge has arrived! The Duke and Duchess of Cambridge posed with the 8-pound newborn. She wore a look from one of her go-to designers, @jennypackham. Tap link in bio for more. #wwdeye #princeofcambridge
Jewelry label @alisonlou has made a name for itself with fine jewelry that speaks to the Millennial market. Now @twallz21 reports that the label is bringing those playful ideas to a new affordable line of lucite hoops with the launch of Loucite by Alison Lou. Here’s a look from the line modeled by @emrata. #wwdaccessories
@sarahjessicaparker and @gilt are teaming up on a bridal ready-to-wear line. Tomorrow, Parker will launch SJP by Sarah Jessica Parker Bridal — and as part of the launch, Gilt will offer 15 exclusive styles from the SJP by Sarah Jessica Parker footwear collection that were designed to complement the new line. Made out of 10 styles, the line is designed for a variety of occasions, from bridal showers to receptions. Get more details on WWD.com #wwdfashion
A grooming moment between @tanfrance and @antoni last night at the The LGBT Community Center Trailblazer Awards honoring Anna Wintour, Ricky Martin and more. See more photos at WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: @lexieblacklock)
“It was a very surreal feeling. It wasn’t like we were in the studio together coming up with it — it’s more like he discovered it and loved it. I didn’t let myself get my hopes up, but then it happened it was very exciting,” said singer-songwriter @nombe on discovering that @pharrell would be using his song, “Cant Catch Me” on his HBO documentary series “Outpost.” The German-born singer — named Noah MacBeth — talked to WWD about feminism, using art as a platform for political expression and personal style. Read more on WWD.com #wwdeye (📷: @jilliansollazzo)
This season, denim is going west – in influence. Brands like @fathersdaughterla (pictured here), @tommyhilfiger Jeans, @levis and more are opting for raw, top-stitching styles. (Styled by @thealexbadia; 📷: @ryanplett)