NEW YORK — It was a lot like the first day back from summer vacation.
Lawyers from Macy’s Inc., Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc. and J.C. Penney Co. Inc. practically skipped into the courtroom Monday to resume the well-publicized contract dispute, but little did they know that by the end of the day, Penney’s chief executive officer Ron Johnson would be out. It’s unclear what impact his departure may have on the case since he was the architect of Penney’s deal with MSLO. Penney’s did not return calls seeking comment, and MSLO’s legal team declined to comment.
“Welcome back, folks,” Oing mumbled Monday as he resumed what has already amounted to a grueling and contentious three-week trial over whether Martha Stewart can sell her branded goods in both Macy’s and Penney’s stores.
Stewart inked a deal in 2007 to sell certain branded goods to Macy’s exclusively. That agreement was allegedly breached when she signed a competing contract with Penney’s at the end of 2011 to sell her branded wares in shops-in-shop this spring, according to Macy’s. As part of that contract, MSLO also sold a 16.6 percent stake to Penney’s. The bold moves were central to Johnson’s vision to reinvent the struggling Penney’s, and those aggressive advances attracted Stewart to jump aboard.
Before the recess, the judge had been mulling over broadening the preliminary injunction he issued last summer. The injunction barred Penney’s from selling Stewart-branded goods in stores beginning this month. Most recently, the judge contemplated whether the ruling should include product designed by Stewart but rebranded with the “JCP Everyday” and “double-house” logo.
The judge said Monday he would hear arguments on this topic Thursday, a day after Macy’s is expected to rest its case.
“Rest means rest,” urged an exasperated Mark Epstein, lawyer for Penney’s, after Macy’s counsel indicated it may have rebuttals after Wednesday. Epstein said “his blood boils” every time Macy’s brings up last minute issues.
“Even after three weeks?” said the judge.
Eric Seiler, MSLO’s lawyer, said once Macy’s rests its case Wednesday morning, he will argue to dismiss “large portions” of the plaintiff’s case that afternoon.
One issue the judge was keen to wrap up sooner concerns Stewart-branded stemware being sold on Penney’s Web site.
According to Macy’s, the sale of the plastic glasses violated the court’s injunction, but lawyers for the defendants said they were under the impression that the glasses didn’t fall under the exclusive categories deemed by Macy’s. According to the defense, plastic glasses could fall under the “celebrations” category, a non-exclusive category. But counsel for MSLO and Penney’s said they would consult with their clients and get back to the judge Tuesday, which is when this minor issue is expected to be resolved by Oing.
Meanwhile, the trial moved forward when Macy’s called John Tighe to the stand. Tighe, Penney’s men’s division general merchandising manager and ex-senior vice president of its home business, gave a thorough three-and-a-half hour testimony about his involvement in the MSLO/JCP deal.
After establishing that Penney’s had identified Martha Stewart as one of the “most powerful” home brands, Macy’s lawyer Theodore Grossman asked Tighe about his dealings with Stewart.
One of Tighe’s more illuminating insights came when he described a conversation with Stewart during which the domestic goods guru expressed unhappiness with her Macy’s contract.
“She believed she should be doing more business,” Tighe said, adding that Stewart also “believed” the private label brands at Macy’s “competed with” her brand, and ultimately detracted from its sales.
Tighe said Stewart thought that she should “almost be getting a percentage of the [Macy’s private label] business,” as her wares, stocked in adjacent shelves, drove private label sales.
She believed they were “feeding off” her brand, the Penney’s executive said of the private label business.
He added that Stewart was excited at the prospect of having a store within Penney’s that would sell her kitchenwares, and that he was told that Stewart’s “ability” to sell her goods within shops-in-shop “dovetailed perfectly” with Johnson’s “vision.”
When he came aboard as ceo in 2011, Johnson began mapping out a strategy to reinvent the midtier department store. He settled on developing shops-in-shop, which offered “everyday” competitive pricing. He began aggressively courting Stewart, who claimed to be somewhat frustrated with the slowing growth of her brand at Macy’s. Stewart had wanted to branch out and not only sell other categories such as luxury bath, but also she wanted her own stand-alone store. The latter was an option, according to her deal with Macy’s. Penney’s seized on that “loophole,” according to Macy’s, and found a way to offer Stewart-branded goods in shops-in-shop in Penney’s.
For the lawsuit, the definition of a store has become vital, but so, too, has the question of confidentiality and suppliers.
Grossman spent a fair amount of time rehashing the issue of suppliers, intimating that perhaps confidential information could be shared if the same supplier was used by MSLO to make goods for both Macy’s and Penney’s.
Tighe said many retailers share “the best suppliers,” and that it’s not a secret that many competitors use the same suppliers. It’s the designs that are proprietary, he argued, noting that MSLO put two separate design teams in place for Penney’s and Macy’s accounts. He added that when it came to store design, MSLO and Penney’s formed a “joint-oversight committee” to monitor MSLO/JCP store designs.
“It was not a typical licensing agreement,” Tighe said, referring to the MSLO/JCP deal. “It was more detailed. It was more collaborative.”
Nicole Post, a senior brand director at Penney’s, took the stand after Tighe. Post, who will resume her testimony Tuesday morning, spoke briefly about the design process and her work as a liaison between Penney’s and the Martha Stewart team. Following the conclusion of Post’s testimony, Katheryn Burchett, Penney’s senior vice president of merchandising and marketing integration, is expected to testify.
@tradesy is turning the concept of a showroom upside down with its new space in Santa Monica. Here, the company plans to hold events, art exhibits and a showcase rare fashion pieces like this Louis Vuitton boxing set. Get all the details on Tradesy’s first showroom on WWD.com. #wwdnews
Spotted last night at the @erdem x @hm launch event: Kate Bosworth, Rashida Jones, Kirsten Dunst and Selma Blair. The party, which took place in LA, also marked the opening of their pop-up shop. “I was interested in creating a collection that wasn’t in any way disposable. It was about pieces you’d create and keep forever, things that have a permanence to it,” designer Erdem Moralioglu said. #wwdeye (📷: Katie Jones)
Renee Zellweger in yellow in 2001 and again in 2017. Chosen as one of the 12 @pantone Leading Spring Colors (and dubbed “Meadowlark”), it only makes sense that the bright hue stands the test of time and is making a resurgence this season, seen already on stars like @blakelively and @gigihadid. (📷: Donato Sardello & @rexfeatures) #wwdfashion #tbt
Dior’s 70th anniversary celebration continues with a new exhibition at the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto. “Christian Dior,” which is scheduled to run through March 18, takes a look at the founders tenure from 1947 to 1057 and feature 40 designs. Pictured here is an evening gown from the Ailée, fall 1948-49 haute couture collection. #wwdfashion (📷: Brian Boyle)
As one of the most recognizable models in the world, Christy Turlington Burns has an insider’s view of the fashion industry and the allegations of sexual harassment swirling around it. “I can say that harassment and mistreatment have always been widely known and tolerated in the industry. The industry is surrounded by predators who thrive on the constant rejection and loneliness so many of us have experiences at some point in our careers,” Turlington told WWD, along with her suggestions for how the modeling world should protect younger women and men. Read more on WWD.com. Link in bio. (📷: Tony Palmieri) #wwdnews
@asics America has tapped a new brand ambassador: famed DJ/record producer @steveaoki. This initiative is intended to set the tone for the new brand identity and philosophy and will include partnerships with influencers and in-store and off-line activations that will continue into next year. This is Asics’ most significant marketing effort in two decades, and is expected to attract younger consumers to the brand. #wwdfashion
24-year-old Jean Prounis is redefining the rules of jewelry. Formerly a studio assistant to Jemima Kirke and a design apprentice at Ghuran, she focuses on handcrafted subtleties and ancient goldsmithing techniques. “There was a really sterile feel in the environment and I wanted to have jewelry with character that shapes how you wear it everyday,” Prounis said. Each piece is hand made in New York, either by Prounis or three other jewelers in the district. #wwdfashion
“These collections continue to build on that vision, empowering differently abled adults to express themselves through fashion,” said @tommyhilfiger of his line of adaptive apparel, which launches today. The line consists of 37 men’s and 34 women’s styles based upon the pieces from the spring Tommy Hilfiger sportswear collection. #wwdnews